[keycloak-dev] menu refactor, removed breadcrumbs

Stan Silvert ssilvert at redhat.com
Thu Aug 14 17:52:49 EDT 2014


On 8/12/2014 11:11 AM, Bill Burke wrote:
> Stian mentioned months and months ago that he thought breadcrumbs were
> redundant.  So...I removed them.
If it doesn't cause other problems, I'd like to request the 
reinstatement of the bread crumbs.

I've found that the breadcrumbs are not always redundant.   Any time you 
choose something from a list and then from there you need to use another 
page with a list, you can get lost and need a lot of clicks to get 
back.  I think the only time this is a problem right now is when adding 
a Role to an Application.  But it will likely come up again in the future.

Let's say I need to add several roles to an application.  I'm in 
Applications --> MyApp --> Roles --> Add Role.

To add a second role without breadcrumbs, I need to go all the way out 
and do several clicks:
Click Applications on lefthand menu
Find my App again in the (possibly long) list
Click on Roles again
Click Add

If I still had breadcrumbs this task would always be two clicks instead 
of four or more.  Also, forcing you to go all the way out to the 
lefthand menu and re-navigate the list seems wrong.


>
> Also, I added a top=level menu item "roles".  This made the settings
> submenu a bit smaller.
>
> Bill
>



More information about the keycloak-dev mailing list