[mod_cluster-dev] Powering down a worker

[jean-frederic clere]

On 06/09/2010 02:43 PM, Bela Ban wrote:
> I have the scenario where I run httpd/mod-cluster on an EC2 instance and 
> a few workers on different EC2 instances.
> 
> When I "terminate" a worker instance (using the EC2 GUI), apparently the 
> virtual instance is terminated *ungracefully*, ie. similar to just 
> pulling the power plug. This means that the shutdown scripts (in 
> /etc/rc0.d) are not run, and the open sockets (e.g. to mod-cluster) are 
> not closed, so mod-cluster won't remove the worker.
> 
> When I look at mod_cluster_manager, it continues listing the killed 
> worker in OK state.

With CR2? Well at least for 5 seconds normally.

> 
> My questions:
> 
>     * I recall that, unlike mod-jk, mod-cluster doesn't have
>       cping/cpong, or any other heartbeating mechanism. Is this correct
>       ?

It has a heartbeating logic so it should detect the dead node.

> So would mod-cluster detect a worker's unreachability, e.g. when
>       I pull the plug on the switch connecting the worker to mod-cluster ?

Yep, otherwise there is a bug somewhere. It would interesting to use
debug in the httpd conf file and mail the corresponding error log. (Or
open a JIRA and put the error_log file there).

>     * I though that the workers detect when a member has crashed and the
>       cluster master then notifies the proxy. So when we have workers
>       {A,B,C}, and C crashes ungracefully, wouldn't A notify the proxy
>       of C's death, so the proxy can remove C ?

Yep that should work too.

Cheers

Jean-Frederic