[rules-dev] Github commit rights cleanup

[Tihomir Surdilovic]

I'm not sure if I'm completely "down" with this idea. Still think that 
giving a community member who has done a great job commit rights is a 
form of reward and trust in that person and that it could motivate them 
to keep contributing/feeling closer to the core team and the project 
(and shows their picture on the members project tab too).

WDYT?
Tihomir
On 2/14/13 8:57 AM, Geoffrey De Smet wrote:
> Of course :)
>
> Not removing laune and nheron either.
>
> Op 14-02-13 14:51, Wolfgang Laun schreef:
>> If the proposed "remove" wouldn't let me do quick fixes like today's -
>> as you proposed - then you might want to let me keep this right, at
>> your discretion ;-)
>>
>> -W
>>
>> On 14/02/2013, Geoffrey De Smet <ge0ffrey.spam at gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Hi guys,
>>>
>>> Stemming from the SVN era, a lot of community contributers still have
>>> full commit rights on the blessed repositories.
>>> Because GitHub offers the "pull request" paradigm,
>>> the lack of commit rights are far less intrusive than in SVN.
>>>
>>> Many community contributors seem to prefer contributing changes through
>>> pull request paradigm,
>>> as it forces a core developer to sign off on the changes.
>>> Having direct commit rights can even be counter-intuitive:
>>> for example, if you edit a file directly on github, it doesn't create a
>>> pull request, but applies the changes directly.
>>> Commits from contributors that come in via pull requests are still
>>> attributed to the original author
>>> and count towards the original author's stats, so there are no
>>> additional disadvantages.
>>>
>>> Following that logic, I propose to *remove the commit rights on blessed
>>> for these contributors* in 72 hours:
>>> Please note that we appreciate past and future commits. Please keep the
>>> contributions coming! :)
>>>
>>> bauna
>>> bbrodt
>>> dennyxu
>>> dgutierr
>>> diega
>>> jcoleman0redhat0com
>>> jrenaat
>>> jsvitak
>>> JuanmaGonzalez
>>> KurtStam
>>> laune
>>> lazarotti
>>> leogomes
>>> lucazamador
>>> michaelneale
>>> michiBK
>>> mswiderski
>>> nheron
>>> nickboldt
>>> nmirasch
>>> pefernan
>>> RickJWagner
>>> ryanzhang
>>> saifulomar
>>> tkobayas
>>> trefor
>>> wmedvede
>>> yurloc
>>>
>>> If you're on this list and want to keep your commits rights on blessed,
>>> just reply to this mail and I 'll take you off the list. No long
>>> argumentation needed :)
>>>
>>> *Keep commits rights on the blessed repositories*
>>>
>>> etirelli
>>> ge0ffrey
>>> jervisliu
>>> krisv
>>> manstis
>>> mariofusco
>>> mdproctor
>>> mrietveld
>>> porcelli
>>> pzapata
>>> Rikkola
>>> Salaboy
>>> sotty
>>> tsurdilo
>>>
>>> *Might keep commits right on the blessed repositories*
>>> I 'll ask these people what they prefer and do that.
>>>
>>> esteban-aliverti
>>> triceo
>>> zenix
>>>
>>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> rules-dev mailing list
>> rules-dev at lists.jboss.org
>> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-dev
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> rules-dev mailing list
> rules-dev at lists.jboss.org
> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-dev