Pavel Sturc Steven Tobin found the cert in AWS Certificate Manager:

From looking there it seems to already be covering both already:

• Domain: community.skunkhenry.com
• Additional Names: *.community.skunkhenry.com

What is confusing to me however is that there are two load balancers with the name: fh-lb-comm1-ocp-master

See:

One is a classic and the other is an application one. Both had a cert attached to the SSL listener a community.skunkhenry.com via IAM. I switched this to ACM instead on both, and it appears to now show a valid SSL connection when I visit the Openshift console.

I hope this fixes the issue Pavel Sturc.