Explicitly setup in Bean Validation, not in JPA ----------------------------------------------- Key: FORGE-1479 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/FORGE-1479 Project: Forge Issue Type: Sub-task Components: UI - Shell Affects Versions: 2.0.0.CR2 Reporter: Antonio Goncalves Assignee: George Gastaldi Fix For: 2.x Future Just after a creating a project, a create a new entity without setting up the persistence ({{jpa-setup}}) : {code} ***SUCCESS*** Project named 'test' has been created. [test]$ jpa-new-entity --named Author [Author.java]$ jpa-new-field --named firstname --length 50 ***SUCCESS*** Field firstname created {code} This hasn't created a {{persistence.xml}} file. But on the other hand, if I want to add a constraint on the entity, I need to explicitelly setup Bean Validation : {code} [Author.java]$ con connection-profile-create connection-profile-remove constraint-setup [Author.java]$ constraint-setup ***SUCCESS*** Bean Validation is installed. [Author.java]$ con connection-profile-create connection-profile-remove constraint-add constraint-setup [Author.java]$ constraint-add --constraint NotNull --onProperty firstname ***SUCCESS*** Constraint NotNull successfully configured {code} if most of the information is giving at project creation, do we still need to explicitly setup Java EE components ? At the moment we have the following : {code} servlet-setup ejb-setup soap-setup cdi-setup jms-setup rest-setup jpa-setup faces-setup jstl-setup jta-setup constraint-setup {code} Most of these commands do not have parameters (except for persistence, rest, validation). So why not activate them by default (or only if {{export ACCEPT_DEFAULTS=true}} ) ? Something like : "if the command {{constraint-add}} is entered, Forge would go {{if constraint is not setup, then I invoke constraint-setup}}", "if the command {{ejb-new}} is entered, Forge would go {{if ejb is not setup, then I invoke ejb-setup}}" That would save some bugs (developers forgetting to setup things), less typing and shorter scripts.