| Sébastien Tardif, an "implicit" join for collection elements has not been supported for many years. An (invalid} example of an implicit join on a collection: select c.users from Company c where c.id=:id Joins to a collection must be explicit, as in: select u from Company c join c.users u where c.id=:id If you are having trouble using an explicit join using 5.2.13, then please attach a runnable test case. Test templates can be found at: https://github.com/hibernate/hibernate-test-case-templates Please let us know, even if it is not a problem using 5.2.13. If it is not a problem when using an explicit join, then we would like to close this very old issue. |