Hi

I would like to know if the EG is aware of this issue. I know people here sometimes are busy, but the intention is contribute in JSF 2.0 Rev A, given a final draft has been released to public (or is it too late for changes?).

regards,

Leonardo Uribe

2010/7/10 Leonardo Uribe <lu4242@gmail.com>
Hi

That's cool. Just one minor comment. Looking the documentation I saw UIData.getClientId still return the id with the rowIndex added.

In the mails to this list with this subject:


[jsr-314-open] Ajax inside a DataTable

It was told it is better to change the behavior of UIData.getClientId, to it does not include the id and instead set this behavior on UIData.getContainerClientId. This requires some small changes on UIData.invokeOnComponent (call UIData.getContainerClientId instead UIData.getClientId) and other methods, but it seems the way to go. Could you please consider this change to be included in Rev A?

I created a spec issue here:

https://javaserverfaces-spec-public.dev.java.net/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=865

Thanks a lot for you attention. I'll keep an eye if this is finally include in JSF 2.0 Rev A. I already committed this change on myfaces but if it is not accepted or deffered by some reason to 2.1 I'll revert those changes.

best regards,

Leonardo Uribe

2010/7/10 Ed Burns <edward.burns@oracle.com>

Hello Experts,

As mentioned at the 20100707 Expert Community meeting, here is the release
candidate 1 of the JSF 2.0 Rev a specification. [1].  There really isn't
any room for modifications for 2.0 Rev a at this point, but if you find
something major, please let me know.  Otherwise, please continue to log
issues in the javaserverfaces-spec-public issuetracker.

Please keep in mind this description of 2.0 Rev a when reviewing it,
taken from the javaserverfaces-spec-public home page.

 This effort will include work that does not require any change in
 behavior of the implementation (including any signature changes) or
 TCK. This work will be limited to spec edits. This work will be
 conducted under the JCP Minor Revision process. Because there are no
 implementation changes, no new release of the Reference Implementation
 (RI) or Test and Compatibility Kit (TCK) will be produced to accompany
 2.0 Rev a. The existing JSF 2.0 RI and TCK will be sufficient for this
 purpose.

For my money, the more interesting release is 2.1, which is currently in
progress.

Thanks,

Ed

[1] https://javaserverfaces-spec-public.dev.java.net/servlets/ProjectDocumentList?folderID=12309&expandFolder=12309&folderID=12309

--
| edburns@oracle.com | office: +1 407 458 0017
| homepage:          | http://ridingthecrest.com/