Your explanation is absolutely superb.  I modified my drl as per your suggestions and it's just been completely transformed. Just one question regarding one suggestion below :
 
-- is this something like a for each loop in java . This is the first example i have seen in drl
-- will this automatically iterate over as many languages as have been inserted ?
-- the inserts .. don't they have to be within a rule block ? or did you just omit other things to keep it simple
insert( new Language( "Japanese" ) );
insert( new Language( "French" ) );
// more of the same

rule "PolyglottScore"
salience 100
when
   Language( $name : name )
   User ($id : id, language.keySet contains $name", $f_score : language[$name])
   $urslt :  UserResult (id == $id, langScore.keySet not contains $name )
then
    modify( $usrlt ){
       setLangScore($name, $_score)
    }
end
 


From: Wolfgang Laun <wolfgang.laun@gmail.com>
To: Manav <manav7574@yahoo.com>; Rules Users List <rules-users@lists.jboss.org>
Sent: Fri, August 13, 2010 1:37:45 PM
Subject: Re: [rules-users] Caching results in temperory variables

See inline annotations.

On 13 August 2010 04:34, Manav <manav7574@yahoo.com> wrote:
Thanks for your response Greg. As you said this is what i tried to fix the issue
by creating a UserResult obj that has score as a property and inserting the same
in working memory. I update the results in subsequent rules in the "then"
clause. There are some issues that i faced in this as well :-

-- In my last rule if i want to do a check on score property of  my result
object in the "when" clause the score has not been updated .

-- however if i do the same check in the "then" clause it seems to work
properly.


-- I tried to overcome by doing an update in one of my rules to check if that
would work. That however went into an infinite loop.  So i used the
"lock-on-active true" property . However it seemed to work well for only the
first user object and doesn't work for other user objects that are loaded later.


Below is the sample rule file . If the scenario is not clear pls do let me know
and i will send across the different drls as attachments .



salience 200
when
    User ($id : id)
then
    UserResult urslt = new UserResult ($id);
    insert ($id)

Here I'd expect
       insert( urslt );

Also, to be on the safe side, I always add a pattern
       not( UserResult( id == $id ) )
to avoid the creation of multiple UserResult's for the same User (if there's a minimal chance it might be modified during the following fusillade).

end

rule "JapaneseScore"
salience 100
 
lock-on-active truewhen
    $usr : User (language.keySet contains "Japanese", $j_score :
language["Japanese"])

I prefer to add a binding of User's id:  User( $id == id )
    $urslt :  UserResult (id == $usr.id)
so I can simplify this. Add a constraint to avoid looping:

        $urslt : USerResult( id == $id, langScore.keySet not contains "Japanese" )
 
then
    $usrlt.setLangScore("Japanese", $j_score); 
        update( $usrlt );
end


rule "FrenchScore"
salience 50
Why not 100?
 
lock-on-active true 
not necessary now
 
when
    User (language.keySet contains "French", $f_score : language["French"])
    $urslt :  UserResult (id == $usr.id)
Same as before:
 $urslt :  UserResult (id == $id, langScore.keySet not contains "French" )

then
    $usrlt.setLangScore("French", $_score); 
    update ($usrlt);
end

salience 25
when
    UserResult (score > 4) // does not work
then
    // if ($usr_rslt.getScore() > 4)  --> works well
    // update the db
end

Regards,
Manav


The repetition of rules JapanesScore and FrenchScore could be avoided by inserting static objects

insert( new Language( "Japanese" ) );
insert( new Language( "French" ) );
// more of the same

rule "PolyglottScore"
salience 100
when
   Language( $name : name )
   User ($id : id, language.keySet contains $name", $f_score : language[$name])
   $urslt :  UserResult (id == $id, langScore.keySet not contains $name )
then
    modify( $usrlt ){
       setLangScore($name, $_score)
    }
end

HTH
--W

 


----- Original Message ----
From: Greg Barton <greg_barton@yahoo.com>
To: Manav <manav7574@yahoo.com>; Rules Users List <rules-users@lists.jboss.org>
Sent: Thu, August 12, 2010 9:29:28 PM
Subject: Re: [rules-users] Caching results in temperory variables

You must either update an existing working memory object or insert a new working
memory object with the results.  That's how rules communicate with each other.

GreG

On Aug 12, 2010, at 10:31 AM, Manav <manav7574@yahoo.com> wrote:

Hi,

I am using the version 5.x of drools and i have a scenario where i want to hold
the result of

a test in one rule to a temperory variable . This result will then be used in
another rule that will be fired

later in the sequence .

For ex :

salience 100
when
    User (language.keySet contains "Japanese", $j_score : language["Japanese"])
then
    // do something
end

salience 50
when
    User (language.keySet contains "French", $f_score : language["French"])
then
    // do something
end

salience 25
when
    eval (($j_score + $f_score) > 4)
then
    // update the same to db
end

Is this possible in Drools 5.x ?

Regards,
Manav




_______________________________________________
rules-users mailing list
rules-users@lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users




_______________________________________________
rules-users mailing list
rules-users@lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/rules-users