On Tue, Oct 21, 2008 at 9:24 AM, Ales Justin <ales.justin@gmail.com> wrote:
   I've re-applied Seam-int 5.0.0.CR4 to AS_trunk.
   That should take care of war deployment - I tested it yesterday on
   non-reverted trunk and it worked.

Will this fix any other issues from the previous status besides the war deployment?

Afaik it's fixing these issues:
 - it recognizes war as possible Seam deployment
 - fixes Scanner::getTimestamp
 - changes jms TopicConnection

ok thanks
 


   But I would still need jboss-seam-jpa.war example in 2.1.0.GA
   <http://2.1.0.GA> version.

    - adding Seam war example to AS testsuite
   As I don't think we should move Seam testing version to 2.1.1 in
   current AS_trunk.
   Unless you guys are sure you can deliver 2.1.1.GA <http://2.1.1.GA>

   before JBoss5.GA.
   Which is probably not that hard ... ;-(

I thought the rough plan for GA was a 2-3 weeks away?

Yes.
But my guess is plans have changed a bit,
due to yesterday's full rollback. ;-)

good point ;-)
 


   Otherwise I would suggest the following config:
    - JBoss5.0.GA <http://JBoss5.0.GA> + Seam-2.1.0.GA
   <http://Seam-2.1.0.GA> + Seam-int_5.0.0.GA <http://Seam-int_5.0.0.GA>
    - Seam-2.1.1.GA <http://Seam-2.1.1.GA> + Seam-int_5.1.0.GA
   <http://Seam-int_5.1.0.GA> + JBoss5.1.GA <http://JBoss5.1.GA>
     --> or change it yourself in JBoss5.0.GA <http://JBoss5.0.GA>

    - Seam_before_2.1 + JBoss5.x --> exclude SeamInt deployer

I'm still not understanding what Seam-int_5.0.0.GA <http://Seam-int_5.0.0.GA> is. Is it a deployer specifically for Seam on AS 5?  A sub project that is installed with AS 5 that helps the integration?

Both. :-)

Seam-int is:
1) MC part
 - currently Seam specific deployer
 - hopefully in the future some other optimization

2) AS part
 - JBossAS custom Seam impl; e.g. VFSScanner instead of URLScanner
 - for 2.1.1. we're thinking of optimizing how resources are looked up
  e.g. using JBoss5 existing lookup mechanisms (we already do it for EJB3)
 - MC components can be part of Seam components
  e.g. getting underlying TransactionManager from MC

MC part will not change a lot.
Where AS part will grow with Seam's changes.
e.g. introduction of hooks for resources lookup optimization

How this comes into JBossAS project is under the same name = jboss-seam-int.
I then during the JBossAS instance build, place the in the right places:
 - MC part goes into JBossAS deployers
 - AS part goes into newly created lib-opt directory

Once you deploy your Seam app,
Seam+MC deployer knows which deployments are Seam deployments,
and adds the Seam+AS part into deployment's classpath.
Seam has a list of custom classes and if they are present they are loaded.
e.g. VFS Scanner is checked, before you fallback to URLScanner

Hope this explains it better. ;-)

Yes thank you!



--
blog: http://in.relation.to/Bloggers/Jay