During the weekend I was able to complete first round of tests and fixes of the quickstarts, here is my feedback about it:

Quickstarts 100% working (60):

* bean-validation
* bmt
* carmart
* carmart-tx
* cdi-add-interceptor-binding
* cdi-alternative
* cdi-injection
* cdi-portable-extension
* cdi-veto
* cmt
* deltaspike-authorization
* deltaspike-beanbuilder
* deltaspike-beanmanagerprovider
* deltaspike-deactivatable
* deltaspike-exception-handling
* deltaspike-projectstage
* ejb-in-ear
* ejb-in-war
* ejb-remote
* ejb-security
* ejb-throws-exception
* greeter
* greeter-spring
* helloworld
* helloworld-gwt
* helloworld-html5
* helloworld-jdg
* helloworld-mdb
* helloworld-rf
* helloworld-rs
* helloworld-singleton
* helloworld-ws
* hibernate4
* inter-app
* jax-rs-client
* jta-crash-rec
* jts-distributed-crash-rec
* kitchensink
* kitchensink-angularjs
* kitchensink-deltaspike
* kitchensink-html5-mobile
* kitchensink-jsp
* kitchensink-ml
* kitchensink-ml-ear
* log4j
* logging-tools
* numberguess
* picketlink-authentication-idm-jsf
* picketlink-authentication-jsf
* servlet-filterlistener
* servlet-security
* tasks
* temperature-converter
* wicket-ear
* wicket-war
* wsat-simple
* wsba-coordinator-completion-simple
* wsba-participant-completion-simple
* xml-dom4j
* xml-jaxp


Quickstarts working but with some unexpected exceptions/errors (8):

* cluster-ha-singleton (EJB, HASingleton, JNDI)

  - exception on stop, see http://pastebin.com/zJDTNQUT

  - exception on undeploy, see http://pastebin.com/wLzpwwiL

 
* ejb-asynchronous (EJB)

  - exception after client completes, see http://pastebin.com/u0EVFTAN

* jts (JTA, EJB)
  - when running the cli script remove-its-transactions.cli an exception is seen in the server console log, see http://pastebin.com/yqYCgL04

* kitchensink-ear (JSF, CDI, EJB, JPA, Bean Validation)
  - exception on undeploy, see http://pastebin.com/iiGAWrFE

* mail (JavaMail, JSF, CDI)
  - exception on undeploy, see http://pastebin.com/G6fJhGDc

* payment-cdi-event (CDI)
  - exception on redeploy after making sales on the app, see http://pastebin.com/4CbMTxVA

* richfaces-validation (RichFaces, JSF and Bean Validation)
  - works but writing on app's text boxes throw exception, see http://pastebin.com/cqxcv3xD

* servlet-async (Servlet, CDI, EJB)
  - exception on undeploy, see http://pastebin.com/0xTgeH5E

Quickstarts not working at all (11):

* deltaspike-helloworld-jms (JMS, CDI, DeltaSpike)

  - fails to send mms msg, see http://pastebin.com/9qHxvWkH

* ejb-security-interceptors (EJB, Security)

  - mvn exec:exec fails

  - exception on server see http://pastebin.com/FR9ptxGm

  - exception on client see http://pastebin.com/xdJgLa0q 

* ejb-security-plus (EJB, Security)
  - mvn:exec:exec fails, see http://pastebin.com/cA6tffPt 

* helloworld-errai (Errai, JAX-RS, GWT)
  - exception on deploy, see http://pastebin.com/G1VgtDUU

* helloworld-jms (JMS)
  - mvn clean compile exec:java fails, see http://pastebin.com/d6WLXdZB

* hibernate3 (JSF)
  - deploy fails, see http://pastebin.com/4y74WwY7

* kitchensink-rf (CDI, JSF, JPA, EJB, JPA, JAX-RS, BV)
  - deploy fails, see http://pastebin.com/wfsEfugd

* picketlink-authorization-idm-jpa (CDI, PicketLink)
  - fails to deploy, see http://pastebin.com/c4QMy3St

* shopping cart (EJB)
  - exception when running client, see http://pastebin.com/DV9Whrj6

* tasks-jsf (JSF, JPA)

  - exceptions when using the app, see http://pastebin.com/4uJdMdpc

*  tasks-rs (JPA, JAX-RS)
  - deploy fails, see http://pastebin.com/iYy2KSM7

Quickstarts not tested due to dependencies on JBoss products or something else (6):

* forge-from-scratch

  - needs JBoss Forge

* helloworld-osgi

  - osgi not included in WFLY 8

* hotrod

  - needs JDG

* kitchensink-cordova

  - some mobile apps(?!?) that I’m not sure how to test

* memcached-endpoint
  - needs JDG

* rest-endpoint
  - needs JDG

—————————

Sources:

* BOMs

  - https://github.com/emmartins/jboss-eap-boms/tree/1.4.0.Final-WFLY8

* Quikstarts

  - https://github.com/emmartins/quickstart/tree/javaee-7.0

To try this checkout both specific branches, do "mvn install" on both, then follow instructions in each Quickstart’s README.md.

——————————

Final Words

Like I said in today’s call, we have a big list of 100% working quickstarts already, probably more than enough as companion of WFLY 8 Final release, but some of the ones that do not work partially or completely kind of worry me, so I’m going to retry the ones which failed with current WildFly sources in master branch. In case the errors persist I will contact related core team members and start digging.

By the way, the Hibernate 3 one, do we need to worry with this or should I simply remove it right away?

With respect to the ones not worked out, I don’t think it makes any sense to use WFLY with other JBoss comercial products, perhaps a change to related community projects should be done later...

There is a final pass of fixes in the README.md files, since during tests I noted there are still a lot of references to EAP 6, but that is not relevant to the WFLY 8 code release.

—E

_______________________________________________
wildfly-dev mailing list
wildfly-dev@lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/wildfly-dev