[windup-dev] Windup Meeting Minutes - 2015-05-27

Minutes: http://transcripts.jboss.org/meeting/irc.freenode.org/windup/2015/windup.... Minutes (text): http://transcripts.jboss.org/meeting/irc.freenode.org/windup/2015/windup.... Log: http://transcripts.jboss.org/meeting/irc.freenode.org/windup/2015/windup.... Meeting summary --------------- * Agenda (lincolnthree, 14:05:10) * Status Reports (lincolnthree, 14:07:43) * Worked on rule review, finishing defining requirements around "what makes a good rule", also touched up the required metadata and information for rules. I will be working on PRs today, then back on rule review. (lincolnthree, 14:11:16) * - Started working on Rule Review (jsightler, 14:11:49) * I also worked on fixing mbriskar's parameterization bug that he found, which meant releasing a new version of Rewrite, currently working on snapshot, still need to release an actual version before we can cut a releaase of windup (lincolnthree, 14:11:53) * Removed Java rule information from the Rules Development Guide (sgilda, 14:11:55) * Updated the quickstarts to replace deprecated code and updated the XML rules to include schema information. (sgilda, 14:11:56) * - I have found a bug in the ast handling that was breaking a few rules, so I have sent a PR for that (jsightler, 14:12:09) * - Also, I have a windup-rulesets pr nearly ready to make it possible to test in the rules-reviewed folder (jsightler, 14:12:44) * Worked on WINDUP-611, WINDUP-612. The main task is WINDUP-610. (ozizka, 14:13:05) * During that, I did some research about what the rules are like, what do they cover, what are the typical sources covering the topics, how to capture them in the rules. (ozizka, 14:13:05) * Then some administrative things like WINDUPRULES- jira, looking around in salesforce, getting my RH KB access, and put few ideas to mailing list and to jira. (ozizka, 14:13:05) * went through https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XJ1LNqhtT8ijZTFROx5OjezOii8TBDI4U... and reviewing xml rules (marekn, 14:13:23) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hJCTf5U4XNnN795MuQXgFGHK0aj3ZG6da... (lincolnthree, 14:19:39) * worked on WINDUP-596, specifically on tests/fixes. There is PR and will probably need some small adjustments (mbriskar_, 14:20:07) * went through "Migration Guide Rules Spreadsheet" and helped adding new rules or eliminating duplicates etc. (mbriskar_, 14:20:51) * : Updated the XML rules documentation to include latest schema information (sgilda, 14:28:05) * Rule ID conventions for rule review (lincolnthree, 14:32:26) * AGREED: Rule ID == ruleset_id + unique_ID (lincolnthree, 14:48:17) * VOTE DASH or UNDERSCORE (lincolnthree, 14:58:22) * brad: dash (lincolnthree, 14:58:39) * underscore (lincolnthree, 14:58:44) * DASH (sgilda, 14:59:37) * AGREED: DASH: weblogic-security-0100 (lincolnthree, 15:00:28) * how many characters for the unique rule GUID? (lincolnthree, 15:02:51) * 8 (sgilda, 15:03:01) * AGREED: Ruleset ID has no UID, RuleID —> weblogic-security-01000 (leaving enough space for 10s of thousands.) (lincolnthree, 15:07:52) * XML rules schema (lincolnthree, 15:08:20) * Schema versioning (lincolnthree, 15:08:53) * windup-jboss-schema-2.3.0.Final.xsd ? (lincolnthree, 15:10:39) * windup-jboss-2.3.0.Final.xsd ? (lincolnthree, 15:11:03) * windup-jboss-2.3.0.Final.xsd for schema name (also provide versionless schema that stays up to date: windup-jboss.xsd for schema name? (lincolnthree, 15:19:36) * LINK: http://www.springframework.org/schema/context/ (marekn, 15:19:38) * AGREED: windup-jboss-2.3.0.Final.xsd for schema name (also provide versionless schema that stays up to date: windup-jboss.xsd for schema name (lincolnthree, 15:20:54) * LINK: https://github.com/windup/windup/blob/master/config-xml/tests/src/test/re... (lincolnthree, 15:22:08) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zPWmiFK7YQiZ7_zYot__3PoobwSA7dS29Y4aQ... ? (mbriskar_, 15:23:00) * IDEA: We could add tags to <classification tags="spring, webservices" ...> to allow filtering and grouping by that in the report (ozizka, 15:31:13) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zPWmiFK7YQiZ7_zYot__3PoobwSA7dS29Y4aQ... (lincolnthree, 15:32:48) * LINK: http://pastebin.com/t96HN9nB (ozizka, 15:42:09) * JBDS plugin state? (Briefly) (lincolnthree, 16:05:53) * pending, not being worked on except critical bugfixes that interfere with demos (lincolnthree, 16:06:15) * Links to community websites (lincolnthree, 16:06:18) * create KB articles for information that is contained in community answers sites (lincolnthree, 16:06:48) * Hint vs. classification - where to put what links, wording, Mardown usage, mixed content (lincolnthree, 16:06:53) * discussed and fixed in schema definition: documented ( https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zPWmiFK7YQiZ7_zYot__3PoobwSA7dS29Y4aQ... ) (lincolnthree, 16:07:16) * <TODO/> for the missing KBs? (lincolnthree, 16:07:19) * Create KB articles when the hint message will be too long. (lincolnthree, 16:09:02) * JIRAs for missing documentation to be created in respective projects issue tracker (e.g. EAP7) (lincolnthree, 16:09:49) * JIRA will be assigned to Sande (lincolnthree, 16:09:57) * AGREED: We can use EAP docs jira to create KB requests (ozizka, 16:09:59) * Gilles Bardouillet's use case - how to write into a XML rule? (lincolnthree, 16:10:16) Meeting ended at 16:14:54 UTC. -- Lincoln Baxter, III http://ocpsoft.org "Simpler is better."