[cdi-dev] [JBoss JIRA] (CDI-625) When exactly are events with @Initialized(X.class) and @Destroyed(X.class) qualifiers fired

[Martin Kouba (JIRA)]

     [ https://issues.jboss.org/browse/CDI-625?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]

Martin Kouba updated CDI-625:
-----------------------------
    Description: 
The spec states that {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired when a context is initialized and {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} when a context is destroyed (note that for {{@ApplicationScoped}} the wording leaves out the context: _"when the application is destroyed"_). 

Does it mean that:
* {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired *after the initialization* of a context is finished, i.e. the context is ready?
* {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} is fired *after the destruction* of a context is finished, i.e. after all the beans are destroyed?

I'm asking because for {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} it might be useful to perform some cleanup before the context is actually destroyed - see also CDI-601.

In RI/Weld, the behaivour of {{@Destroyed(ApplicationScoped.class)}} is currently a little bit inconsistent. For webapps and Weld SE, the event is fired before the context is destroyed. But for non-web EE modules (e.g. ejb jar) the event is fired after the context is destroyed.

I believe this should be more clear.


  was:
The spec states that {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired when a context is initialized and {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} when a context is destroyed (note that for {{@ApplicationScoped}} the wording leaves out the context: _"when the application is destroyed"_). 

Does it mean that:
* {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired *after the initialization* of a context is finished, i.e. the context is ready?
* {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} is fired *after the destruction* of a context is finished, i.e. after all the beans are destroyed?

I'm asking because for {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} it might be useful to perform some cleanup before the context is actually destroyed - see also CDI-601.

In RI/Weld, the behaivour of {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} is currently a little bit inconsistent. For webapps and Weld SE, the event is fired before the context is destroyed. But for non-web EE modules (e.g. ejb jar) the event is fired after the context is destroyed.

I believe this should be more clear.




> When exactly are events with @Initialized(X.class) and @Destroyed(X.class) qualifiers fired
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: CDI-625
>                 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/CDI-625
>             Project: CDI Specification Issues
>          Issue Type: Clarification
>          Components: Events
>            Reporter: Martin Kouba
>              Labels: F2F2016
>             Fix For: 2.0 (proposed)
>
>
> The spec states that {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired when a context is initialized and {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} when a context is destroyed (note that for {{@ApplicationScoped}} the wording leaves out the context: _"when the application is destroyed"_). 
> Does it mean that:
> * {{@Initialized(X.class)}} is fired *after the initialization* of a context is finished, i.e. the context is ready?
> * {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} is fired *after the destruction* of a context is finished, i.e. after all the beans are destroyed?
> I'm asking because for {{@Destroyed(X.class)}} it might be useful to perform some cleanup before the context is actually destroyed - see also CDI-601.
> In RI/Weld, the behaivour of {{@Destroyed(ApplicationScoped.class)}} is currently a little bit inconsistent. For webapps and Weld SE, the event is fired before the context is destroyed. But for non-web EE modules (e.g. ejb jar) the event is fired after the context is destroyed.
> I believe this should be more clear.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.4.11#64026)