[hibernate-dev] [HSEARCH] Extract core of HSEARCH query engine to be independent of Hibernate Core.

[Emmanuel Bernard]

On 23 févr. 2011, at 18:13, Sanne Grinovero wrote:

> I've been trying to port current work in progress as dependency of
> Infinispan Query,
> I'm wishing for these changes:
> 
> 1) TimeoutManager should throw specific exceptions directly, depending
> on the framework being used
> (see the pull request I sent you [1], I think it solves the issue, we
> might want to polish it a bit to have the JPA interface define it's
> own specific factory.

I'll have a look

> 
> 2) The org.hibernate.search.engine.Loader interface:
> I'd just remove the init() method from the interface.
> Infinispan Query needs quite different types and parameters (and
> definitely not a Session), and I see no reason to have the init method
> expressed by the interface contract.
> Each framework should know how to create and initialize his specific loaders.

Loader is not a public API. If we ever expose it, that's going to be fore Hibernate Core's object loading.
In other words, I have the feeling that Loader cannot be reused between various object sources. Does ISPN's Query module use them? Did you manager to reuse much code in practice?