[jboss-dev-forums] [Design of POJO Server] - Re: Scoping of war/jar file embedded in sar service archives

[scott.stark@jboss.org]

"adinn" wrote : 
  | I worked out by trial and error that removing the classpath entries in the war file manifest solves the class duplication problem. I assume this is because the war class loader grabs its own copy of classes in the the jars (recursively) mentioned in the classpath rather than delegating to the sar loader.
  | 
Yes, the default war model is to use any class in its classpath before delegating to the parent unless either the web deployer or a jboss-web.xml changes this.

"adinn" wrote : 
  | I did not actually need to remove the jar classpath entries to fix the problem and assume this would not be strictly necessary since the entries only reference jars contained within the same sar i.e. they do not intercede between the loader of the referencing class and some other loader. Is that a valid assumption or was I just lucky? I'll still remove the classpath entries anyway -- the app works fine without them.
  | 
Its doubtful the jar classpath entries have any affect as the referenced jars are already part of the deployment classpath. No reason to remove them. 

"adinn" wrote : 
  | I don't know whether this needs to be documented as a bug, change of behaviour or just useful thing someone might want to know some day. Anyway, it probably ought to be noted somewhere where AS users or the support team can find it (well, it is noted here at least :-)
  | 
I just want to understand what the difference is. It sounds like the war manifest classpath behavior has changed, but if anything I would expect that in jbossas5 the war manifest was ignored while what you describe appears to be the opposite; that 4.X/5.0.BetaX were not using the war manifest classpath. I think we have gone around on whether the war manifest classpath should be picked up or not.

At this point I just want to reproduce the issue in a unit test. If I can't tweak my current example I'll need to get your deployment to see what exactly is happening.


View the original post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&p=4163931#4163931

Reply to the post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=posting&mode=reply&p=4163931