[jboss-dev] JBoss Bootstrap, Embedded & Reloaded

[Carlo de Wolf]

Bill Burke wrote:
>
>
> Carlo de Wolf wrote:
>> I think we can say that the entire scope of JBoss Embedded is too 
>> large to handle right now.
>
> To put it bluntly:  This is a bunch of crap.  Either do it right or 
> don't do it at all.  There's no point doing it at all if you're not 
> going to solve user's needs.  You'll just be wasting engineering 
> resources.
Horse shit. That way we wouldn't be able to make any small increase in 
progress. We shouldn't be making progress onto a dead-end path, *that* 
would be wasting engineering resources.
>
>>
>> The tricky bit will be assigning the proper properties to the proper 
>> component while trying to maintain it backwards compatible with what 
>> we have right now.
>>
>
> What I think you need to do is map out *exactly* how you think users 
> are going to use Embedded.  Go through a couple of iterations of it on 
> this list.  I know a few customers that would love to participate in 
> this discussion. (Cisco).  After you flush it out, Implement it.  
> *THEN* figure out how to refactor it so it fits in the grand scheme of 
> things.  You're doing it backwards.
>
The requirements for Embedded in EAP have been discussed on lists and 
calls. If the community wants to add scenarios for Embedded they are 
free to do so.

Carlo