[jbosstools-dev] Content and usage of target platforms (was Re: New mechanism for target=platforms)

[Denis Golovin]

On 09/14/2012 12:19 AM, Max Rydahl Andersen wrote:
>>> For me as a developer .target file is the window to update sites. This window lets in only those versions of bundles/feature we can use in development. For JBT it is features/bundles released for Juno 4.2.0 because I really would like to avoid issues like https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBIDE-12248 (JBoss Tools (Indigo) Installation from Eclipse Marketplace fails for Eclipse Indigo 3.7.0 and 3.7.1). All these means .target file for JBT 4.0.x should not be changed much. The only reason to change it is to add some new dependency(ies) to it and those dependencies should have versions released for 4.2.0 for the same reason explained above.
>>>
>>> Could someone explain what are these unified/local/multiple targets below used for? It looks like they point out to latest version of Juno, which would not let to use them in development process.
>> Hi Denis,
>>
>> This change we're about to make does not affect the content (plugins and features) of the target-platform. Instead it affects what is the process to publish a new platform.
>> I agree with you that the less often .target change for JBT, the less often we may have issues.
>> However, it's not the same for JBDS, for which we want the latest/greatest/stablest version of Eclipse.
> Both JBT and JBDS want the best and greatest to *run* against, but they both should have the "minimal compatibility" to *compile/build* against.
>
> Only the installer/product build of JBDS should use the "latest/greatest" for its binary build.
>
>> You note probably highlight the need for 2 target-platforms: the "minimal compatibiliy" for JBT, and the "Best and greatest" for JBDS.
> Yes.
>
>> About the file we have, I sent some mails a few month ago on this topic, I'll try to sum it up:
>> * multiple.target: points to the composite target site, good to use inside IDE with PDE since it also contains source (PDE is greedy and also finds sources from the composite)
> should really get another name than multiple.
why not:
multiple -> composite
local is replaced by maven mirroring
unified - > aggregated

Denis
>
>> * local.target: if you want to perform lots of local build and save time, just run "mvn install" on local.target, you'll get all the TP repo locally, and you'll be able to consume it in your builds using the -Plocal.target profile. Not that this target is probably going to be replaced by Maven mirrors as soon as Tycho 0.16 is resolved: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBIDE-12608
> yes, always felt wrong.
>
>> * unified.target: resolves against the aggregated target site. It's the one we recommand for "sporadic" local builds.
> "sporadic" ? I thought this was *the* recommended and default one used for builds ?
>
> /max