[rules-users] CEP accumulate unclear behavior

[ters]

laune, thanks for fast reply! So from point to point:

*-- "Are you using 5.4.0?"*
Yes, I'm using 5.4.0.Final.

*-- "But you can easily achieve what you want by adding the pattern
ServicePerformanceEvent() in front of the accumulate CE."*
I've tested this, LHS is:
/        ServicePerformanceEvent()
accumulate(ServicePerformanceEvent(serviceName == "MyService", $thisDuration
: duration);
    		       $avg : average($thisDuration));/

The result is:
-= 1 =-
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
-= 2 =-
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
-= 3 =-
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------
---test end---

Now (e.g. in case -3-) rule fires on all already inserted/processed events!
but I expect (in case -3-) firing only for last inserting event which is not
processed before, that is:
-= 1 =-
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
-= 2 =-
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
/-= 3 =-
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------/
---test end---

*--"Can you try with a later version?"*
I've just tried with 6.0.0.Final version. Now result of Third rule becomes
the same for both fireAllRules and fireUntilHalt tests (good point):
/////Third rule:
	when
		$event : ServicePerformanceEvent(serviceName == "MyService");
        accumulate(ServicePerformanceEvent(serviceName == "MyService",
$thisDuration : duration);  $avg : average($thisDuration));
	then
        System.out.println("$event.duration = " + $event.duration);
        System.out.println("$events avg duration = " + $avg);
        System.out.println("----------FIRED----------");
end		/

Result:
-= 1 =-
$event.duration = 2
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
-= 2 =-
-= 3 =-
$event.duration = 2
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------
$event.duration = 12
$events avg duration = 7.0
----------FIRED----------
---test end---

As can see, in case -3-, rule fires 2 times - on already inserted and
processed as fact event with duration=2 and 
on the event with duration=12 which inserted just now and was not processed
as fact before. 

Actually what I want in this case - the rule should fire only on events
restricted with serviceName constraint, /*which are not 
processed as fact/not-fact before (inserted between fireAllRules() calls)*/,
but average should be calculated for all existed in wm events considering
serviceName constraint.
I.e. my expectation for Third rule result is:
/ -= 1 =-
$event.duration = 2
$events avg duration = 2.0
----------FIRED----------
-= 2 =-
*-= 3 =-
$event.duration = 12
$events avg duration = 7.0*
----------FIRED----------
---test end---/

How I can achieve this behavior???




--
View this message in context: http://drools.46999.n3.nabble.com/CEP-accumulate-unclear-behavior-tp4027069p4027088.html
Sent from the Drools: User forum mailing list archive at Nabble.com.