[seam-dev] Broken validation or broken booking example ?

[Max Rydahl Andersen]

Hi,

In Tools we implemented long ago a validation based on docs and what you  
guys told us in SF:

https://jira.jboss.org/jira/browse/JBIDE-554
"All stateful session bean Seam components must have a method marked  
@Remove @Destroy to ensure that Seam will remove the stateful bean when  
the Seam context ends, and clean up any server-side state."

Recently we created the Project Example wizard and we wanted to use the  
booking example as an example.
I was surprised to find that our validator complained about the code  
because in there all @Stateful beans get the Error:

"Stateful component "<takeyourpick>List" must have a method marked  
@Destroy	

and that is true since the code looks like this:

@Remove
    public void destroy() {}

where it should be:

@Remove @Destroy
    public void destroy() {}

My question now is:

Is that validation rule broken (and the docs are wrong) or is the booking  
example broken ?

Thanks,
-- 
/max