[seam-dev] Re: Seam 2.1CR1 library versions

Sat Sep 27 16:44:39 EDT 2008

why are some libs in example different than in lib?

for example:
  /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-search.jar,3.0.1.SNAPSHOT-20080202,,
  /lib,hibernate-search.jar,3.0.1.GA,,
and
  /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate3.jar,3.2.3.ga,,
  /lib,hibernate.jar,3.2.4.sp1,,
  /lib/gen,hibernate.jar,3.2.4.sp1,,

is there a good reason to have different versions?
wouldn't it be nice to avoid repeating jars at all?

2008/9/26 Jay Balunas <tech4j at gmail.com>:
>
>
> On Fri, Sep 26, 2008 at 6:51 AM, Pete Muir <pmuir at redhat.com> wrote:
>>
>> Quite a few of these are transient from things like RichFaces and also
>> from the modules. They certainly aren't dependencies of Seam!
>>
>> Specifically:
>>
>> commons-collections, commons-digester, commons-beanutils and
>> commons-logging come from RichFaces,
>> commons-beanutils is needed by CDK generated code
>> commons-httpclient, coomons-collections, commons-io, commons-lang is
>> needed by yawfraw (for rss)
>>
>> There is no easy way around the RichFaces deps without eliminating them
>> from RF (which I have asked for in the past). Jay, can you follow up on
>> this?
>
> I will certainly add this to the list of priorities - but this seems pretty
> important.
>
>>
>> As for the RSS stuff, Daniel/Nik I think you investigated whether you can
>> run yawfraw without commons-lang? This is another good reason to have a
>> totally separate modules project as then this stuff doesn't taint core.
>>
>> On 26 Sep 2008, at 09:32, Gavin King wrote:
>>
>>> yeeew, why are we getting all this commons crap?!
>>>
>>> I tried soooo hard to keep garbage like commons-lang out!
>>>
>>> On Fri, Sep 26, 2008 at 2:22 AM, Jozef Hartinger <jharting at redhat.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Differences between Seam 2.1.0 BETA1 and CR1 delver output:
>>>>
>>>> ant.jar, common.jar, freemarker.jar, hibernate-tools.jar, jtidy.jar,
>>>> runtime.jar, text.jar moved to gen folder
>>
>> Correct.
>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> commons-digester.jar
>>>> BETA1: 1.8
>>>> CR1: 1.7 - downgrade?
>>
>> I think this is wrong. Can you file an issue in JIRA.
>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> commons-logging.jar
>>>> BETA1:  1.0.4
>>>> CR1: 1.1
>>
>> Correct.
>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> commons-httpclient.jar, commons-io.jar, commons-lang.jar, yarfraw.jar
>>>> are
>>>> new in CR1
>>
>> Ok.
>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Jozef Hartinger wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Delver tool output:
>>>>>
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,jdom.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,j4j.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-search.jar,3.0.1.SNAPSHOT-20080202,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,jmimemagic-0.1.0.jar,0.1.0,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,commons-lang-2.3.jar,2.3,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,rome-0.9.jar,0.9,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,ws-commons-util-1.0.2.jar,-,No version found in
>>>>> manifest,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,ejb3-persistence.jar,3.0 Final Release March 14
>>>>> 2007,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-validator.jar,3.0.0.GA,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,lucene-highlighter-2.1.0.jar,build 2007-02-14,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-tools.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,xmlrpc-client-3.1.jar,3.1,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,jakarta-oro-2.0.8.jar,2.0.8 2003-12-28 11:00:13,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-annotations.jar,3.3.0.GA,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,dbunit-2.2.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,jboss-archive-browsing.jar,2.0.2.Alpha,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,ehcache-1.3.0.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate3.jar,3.2.3.ga,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,xmlrpc-common-3.1.jar,3.1,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-commons-annotations.jar,3.0.0.GA,,
>>>>> /examples/wiki/lib,hibernate-entitymanager.jar,3.3.1.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,saaj-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-system.jar,4.2.3.GA (build: SVNTag=JBoss_4_2_3_GA
>>>>> date=200807192035),,
>>>>> /lib,commons-beanutils.jar,1.6,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-deployers-core-spi.jar,2.0.0.Beta6,,
>>>>> /lib,lucene-core.jar,2.3.0 613715 - buschmi - 2008-01-21 01:30:48,,
>>>>> /lib,portlet-api.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-remoting.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,cglib.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-jul.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,jsr250-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jaxws-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-pdf.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-embedded-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,ejb-api.jar,3.0,,
>>>>> /lib,ehcache.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,commons-lang.jar,2.3,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-wicket.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,jbpm-jpdl.jar,3.2.2 (date:12-Sep-2007 13:59),,
>>>>> /lib,quartz.jar,1.6.0,,
>>>>> /lib,asm.jar,1.5.3,,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate-search.jar,3.0.1.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,wicket-extensions.jar,1.3.3,,
>>>>> /lib,resteasy-jaxrs.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jsf-api.jar,1.2_09-b01-BETA1,,
>>>>> /lib,core.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-rss.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,jsf-impl.jar,1.2_09-b01-BETA1,,
>>>>> /lib,jsr181-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jgroups.jar,2.4.1,,
>>>>> /lib,commons-httpclient.jar,3.1,,
>>>>> /lib,jfreechart.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-mail.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,urlrewritefilter.jar,3.0.4,,
>>>>> /lib,wicket.jar,1.3.3,,
>>>>> /lib,spring.jar,2.0.6,,
>>>>> /lib,richfaces-api.jar,3.2.2.BETA4,,
>>>>> /lib,janino.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jcommon.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,dbunit.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,meldware-mailapi.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jbosscache-core.jar,2.2.0.CR6,,
>>>>> /lib,slf4j-api.jar,1.4.2,,
>>>>> /lib,yarfraw.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-cache.jar,1.4.1.SP9,,
>>>>> /lib,asm-attrs.jar,1.5.3,,
>>>>> /lib,wicket-datetime.jar,1.3.3,,
>>>>> /lib,jaxb-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,slf4j-log4j12.jar,1.4.2,,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate.jar,3.2.4.sp1,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-logging-spi.jar,2.0.5.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,jta.jar,-,No Manifest File,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate-validator.jar,3.0.0.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,richfaces-ui.jar,3.2.2.BETA4,,
>>>>> /lib,cglib-nodep.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,hsqldb.jar,private-2007/08/31-08:52:19,,
>>>>> /lib,itext-rtf.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jms.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jsr173_api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-ui.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,antlr-runtime.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,drools-core.jar,4.0.4,,
>>>>> /lib,testng.jar,5.6-200706070953,,
>>>>> /lib,bsh.jar,2.0b4 2005-05-23 11:49:20,,
>>>>> /lib,commons-logging.jar,1.1,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-vfs.jar,2.0.0.Beta11,,
>>>>> /lib,servlet-api.jar,2.5,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-excel.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,joda-time.jar,1.4,,
>>>>> /lib,itext.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,activation.jar,1.1,,
>>>>> /lib,ant-antlr.jar,1.7.0,,
>>>>> /lib,concurrent.jar,1.3.4 compiled: February 17 2005,,
>>>>> /lib,el-api.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-jmx.jar,4.2.3.GA (build: SVNTag=JBoss_4_2_3_GA
>>>>> date=200807192035),,
>>>>> /lib,antlr.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,wicket-ioc.jar,1.3.3,,
>>>>> /lib,drools-compiler.jar,4.0.4,,
>>>>> /lib,meldware-mailjmx.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-el.jar,1.0_02.CR2,,
>>>>> /lib,mail.jar,1.4,,
>>>>> /lib,mvel14.jar,1.2.21 January 14 2008,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-ioc.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,groovy-all.jar,1.5.4,,
>>>>> /lib,commons-io.jar,1.3.1,,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate-annotations.jar,3.3.0.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,jxl.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jaxrs-api.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,richfaces-impl.jar,3.2.2.BETA4,,
>>>>> /lib,persistence-api.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /lib,jsp-api.jar,2.1,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-common-core.jar,2.0.4.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-debug.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,dom4j.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-seam-resteasy.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib,commons-digester.jar,1.7,,
>>>>> /lib,jsf-facelets.jar,1.1.15.B1,,
>>>>> /lib,commons-collections.jar,3.2,,
>>>>> /lib,javassist.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate-commons-annotations.jar,3.0.0.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,hibernate-entitymanager.jar,3.3.1.GA,,
>>>>> /lib,jboss-deployers-client-spi.jar,2.0.0.Beta6,,
>>>>> /lib,log4j.jar,1.2.14,,
>>>>> /lib,gwt-servlet.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/interop,jboss-seam-jul.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/interop,jboss-seam-wls-compatible.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/interop/src,jboss-seam-wls-compatible-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/interop/src,jboss-seam-jul-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/test,thirdparty-all.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/test,jboss-embedded-all.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/test,hibernate-all.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,cglib.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,asm.jar,1.5.3,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,jtidy.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,asm-attrs.jar,1.5.3,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,ant.jar,1.7.0,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,hibernate.jar,3.2.4.sp1,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,jta.jar,-,No Manifest File,
>>>>> /lib/gen,bsh.jar,2.0b4 2005-05-23 11:49:20,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,jboss-seam.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,hibernate-tools.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,el-api.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,antlr.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,jboss-el.jar,1.0_02.CR2,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,common.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,text.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,freemarker.jar,2.3.8,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,dom4j.jar,1.6.1,,
>>>>> /lib/gen,runtime.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,javassist.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/gen,jboss-seam-gen.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/gen/src,jboss-seam-gen-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-rss-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-excel-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-resteasy-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-mail-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-pdf-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-remoting-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-ioc-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-wicket-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-debug-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-ui-sources.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /lib/src,jboss-seam-sources.jar,2.1.0.CR1,,
>>>>> /build/maven/lib,maven-2.0.8-uber.jar,1.0,,
>>>>> /build/maven/boot,classworlds-1.1.jar,1.1,,
>>>>> /build/lib,ant-launcher.jar,-,No version found in manifest,
>>>>> /build/lib,ant.jar,1.7.0,,
>>>>> /build/lib,ant-nodeps.jar,1.7.0,,
>>>>> /build/lib,maven-ant-tasks.jar,2.0.10-SNAPSHOT,,
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> Jozef Hartinger
>>>> JBoss QA Intern
>>>> Office phone: +420 532 294 130, ext 82-62 130
>>>> E-mail: jharting at redhat.com
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> seam-dev mailing list
>>>> seam-dev at lists.jboss.org
>>>> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/seam-dev
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> --
>>> Gavin King
>>> gavin.king at gmail.com
>>> http://in.relation.to/Bloggers/Gavin
>>> http://hibernate.org
>>> http://seamframework.org
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> seam-dev mailing list
>>> seam-dev at lists.jboss.org
>>> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/seam-dev
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> seam-dev mailing list
>> seam-dev at lists.jboss.org
>> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/seam-dev
>
>
>
> --
> blog: http://in.relation.to/Bloggers/Jay
>
> _______________________________________________
> seam-dev mailing list
> seam-dev at lists.jboss.org
> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/seam-dev
>
>