[teiid-dev] [teiid-users] Custom connectors

[John Doyle]

Ugliness.  I don't suppose it's possible that we use the 'patch.jar' classpath entry to create a default place to add extensions and patches for the connector?

~jd
----- "Steven Hawkins" <shawkins at redhat.com> wrote:

> Hello all,
> 
> With the JCA work, the current rar packaging for connectors presents a
> few issues with the old way we used to manage dependencies.  For
> example if I want a custom JDBC connection which introduces a new
> connector binding property and custom code, then I would need to
> create a copy of the jdbc rar, add my custom jar, and modify the
> ra.xml file.  Since the jdbc rar contains our jdbc connector jar, now
> there are two copies of that jar.  Management of patching becomes an
> issue.
> 
> Even in a simpler case which is providing my own implementation of
> capabilities of the Translator class would require either that I place
> my custom code in a higher level class loader or create a copied rar
> and add my custom jar.  In the former case there is the possibility of
> class loading issues, in the latter there's the same duplicated
> dependency issue.
> 
> It doesn't seem that there is a simple answer to this problem. 
> Options include:
> 
> 1. Elevating all of the built-in connector jars to the same class
> loader as the connector api.  Now there is a single place to
> manage/patch the dependency.  This path assumes that the xml
> connectors will be refactored to contain only minimal external
> dependencies, otherwise they would still need to be managed as rar.
> 
> 2. Investigate OSGI support
> (http://jbossosgi.blogspot.com/2009/06/jboss-osgi-runtime-as-integration.html)
> so that we can use declared dependencies.  However this is a poor fit
> with the JCA model and adds additional complexities.
> 
> 3. Treat all custom connector work, even extensions of our connectors,
> equally.  Each new type requires a rar and any dependency maintenance
> becomes the responsibility of the customer.
> 
> Any thoughs?
> _______________________________________________
> teiid-users mailing list
> teiid-users at lists.jboss.org
> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/teiid-users