[seam-dev] Need advice on what and how to commit new build stuff for the booking sample app on WebSphere v7

[Denis Forveille]

2009/7/27 Pete Muir <pmuir at redhat.com>

>
> On 27 Jul 2009, at 17:57, Denis Forveille wrote:
>
>  (eg. the build process included specific JBoss libs,
>>
>> Like?
>>
>> jboss-common-core.jar  and concurrent.jar
>>
>
> IIRC these are Hibernate dependencies...
>
>  Well, I would suggest including instructions for getting it working with
>> minimal changes in the readme. You can add a comment to the specifc file
>> like <!-- Not required in WAS 7 -->, and write in the ref guide that you
>> don't need these (but they don't hurt) etc.
>>
>> But as this sample is likely the application people start with, IMHO it
>> would be better to have an application that shows the "best way to run  Seam
>> on your AS".
>> eg, in the doc I will describe three ways to configure the application to
>> let Seam smoothy find the beans in the JNDI WAS namespace. If I give
>> instructions to modify the sample app "with minimal changes" (see your
>> comment below) to run on WAS, it will use the worse way (IMO) to do it (ie
>> maintain the ejb3 ref in the config files) and people will build their apps
>> on this without any real sample app that will use the best approach.
>> If you are OK with it, for WAS, I will give instructions to build the
>> booking application and get the "best way to run Seam on WAS v7", this will
>> include a few extra steps (like remove the ejb-ref etc..)
>>
>
> I would suggest describing both the minimal and recommended.
>
> In other words "If you are getting started with WAS you can do XYZ" "Now
> that you've got the app up and running, you may be wondering if you can
> simplify the configuration. You can by doing PQRST (remove ejb-refs etc.)"
>
> So, we get people up and running with minimum deviation from the EE spec -
> the most portable app. Then we show how to tweak for WAS.
>

Understood and agreed.

I've created a JIRA and will start to work on it.

I'll ask you (or someone else) to review at least the doc when I'll commit
it in v2.2.1 ('cause of my english..) and i may even ask you to add my name
to the "authors"...lol
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.jboss.org/pipermail/seam-dev/attachments/20090727/810cf089/attachment.html