Re: [keycloak-dev] File-based Vault implementation

Hey, We are considering an initial, file-based Vault [1] implementation that we'll ship out of the box. I imagine a minimum set of requirements as the following: - Easy to write by hand (for testing) - Works out of the box in Kubernetes (Kubernetes can mount Secrets as files) - Make sure we do not cache file content anywhere, so we don't compromise a secret value in Keycloak Essentially, there are two approaches for such an implementation. The first option is to put all secrets into a shared file representing key-value pairs (a properties file is a natural candidate for such an implementation). This approach very easy to use but it's pretty hard to search for a particular key in a file. We would need to make sure that we don't cache anything wile parsing the file (in BufferedInputStream for example). Such an implementation would also be pretty slow, since whenever we'd access the vault for a particular key, we would potentially need to search the whole file. The second option is more complicated. Imagine the following file structure (inside a vault directory): my-secret-1 (secret value in its content) my-secret-2 (secret value in its content) my-secret-3 (secret value in its content) In other words, each key is a file in a vault directory and its content corresponds the secret value. Such an implementation is not very easy to use as we'd need to create many small files. However, it's super fast for searching and we can securely read the value without a risk of compromising other secret values provided by the vault. I wonder what do you think about this? My personal take on this is that we should provide both implementations. The former (single file) would be used in our testsuite (because of simplicity) and the latter (multiple files) in production and in Kubernetes. Thanks, Sebastian [1] https://github.com/keycloak/keycloak-community/blob/master/design/secure-... _______________________________________________ keycloak-dev mailing list keycloak-dev(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/keycloak-dev