After some benchmark tests, a point comes where the performance of the JPA repository become a bottle neck. At this point, we are doing tests with: - 21 560 391 COMPOSITE_ROLE rows - 14 774 947 USER_ROLE_MAPPING rows - 1 332 324 KEYCLOAK_ROLE rows - 191 034 CREDENTIAL rows - 191 034 USER_ENTITY rows - 145 905 PROTOCOL_MAPPER_CONFIG rows - 191 033 USER_REQUIRED_ACTION rows - 30 187 PROTOCOL_MAPPER rows - 5 031 CLIENT rows - 10 054 REDIRECT_URIS rows - 5 026 WEB_ORIGINS rows - 6 AUTHENTICATOR_CONFIG_ENTRY rows - 27 COMPONENT_CONFIG rows - 6 IDENTITY_PROVIDER_CONFIG rows - 41 AUTHENTICATION_EXECUTION rows - 16 AUTHENTICATION_FLOW rows - 4 AUTHENTICATOR_CONFIG rows - 2 CLIENT_DEFAULT_ROLES rows - 10 COMPONENT rows - 39 DATABASECHANGELOG rows - 1 DATABASECHANGELOGLOCK rows - 1 DATABASECHANGELOG_EXAMPLE_EN rows - 2 IDENTITY_PROVIDER rows - 1 MIGRATION_MODEL rows - 1 REALM rows - 13 REALM_ATTRIBUTE rows - 2 REALM_DEFAULT_ROLES rows - 1 REALM_EVENTS_LISTENERS rows - 1 REALM_REQUIRED_CREDENTIAL rows - 11 REALM_SUPPORTED_LOCALES rows - 5 REQUIRED_ACTION_PROVIDER rows - 2 SCOPE_MAPPING rows - 1 USER_ATTRIBUTE rows 1) When we are trying to load clients for migration/administration purpose, Keycloak load each client one by one and perform lazy loading. 2) When the administrator delete a client, listeners are notified and some of them reload all clients from the realm to load resources for each occurrence from resourceServerStore one by one in a foreach loop. With the current test volume, that take approximatively 1 hour 3 minutes to : - load reaml's clients into memory - delete 11 clients - delete 50 Users - delete 340 user/role association - delete 85 roles - create 11 clients - create 85 roles - create 50 users - create 340 user/role association After some tuning we can optimize the query and surrounded services to take only 5 minutes *Impacted projects* - keycloak-authz-policy-common - org.keycloak.authorization.policy.provider.user. UserPolicyProviderFactory - keycloak-model-infinispan - org.keycloak.models.authorization.infinispan. CachedResourceServerStore - org.keycloak.models.cache.infinispan.RealmCacheSession - keycloak-model-jpa - org.keycloak.authorization.jpa.entities.ResourceServerEntity - org.keycloak.models.jpa.entities.ClientEntity - org.keycloak.models.jpa.entities.ScopeMappingEntity - org.keycloak.authorization.jpa.store.JPAResourceServerStore - org.keycloak.models.jpa.JpaRealmProvider - keycloak-server-spi-private - org.keycloak.authorization.store.ResourceServerStore - org.keycloak.authorization.store.syncronization.RealmSynchronizer - org.keycloak.authorization.store.syncronization.UserSynchronizer - org.keycloak.migration.migrators.MigrateTo2_1_0 - keycloak-services - org.keycloak.authorization.admin.AuthorizationService - org.keycloak.services.resources.admin.ClientsResource _______________________________________________ keycloak-dev mailing list keycloak-dev(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/keycloak-dev