7:01 a.m.
Goal:
Setup custom federation which extends ldap provider.
Question: What is the proper way to extend the ldap federation while adding
one more configuration input? (without changing internal keycloak files)
I followed the steps in
https://www.keycloak.org/docs/latest/server_development/index.html#_user-...
and specify my own provider and providerFactory,
In admin console, when trying to create the federation "custom-ldap", most
of the input fields do not have a label and some buttons like "Test
connection" are missing. The configuration property that I added and
customized has label/default value/tooltip.
If it is not possible to extend the form, is there an easy way how to
inherit the same UI form from the ldap federation page in my extension?
(Im new to keycloak, and do not have experience with Freemarker).
Thank you so much for your support,
David
5:54 a.m.
Hey David,
On Thu, Aug 22, 2019 at 2:15 PM David VS <david.vsaraiva(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Goal:
Setup custom federation which extends ldap provider.
Question: What is the proper way to extend the ldap federation while adding
one more configuration input? (without changing internal keycloak files)
I followed the steps in
https://www.keycloak.org/docs/latest/server_development/index.html#_user-...
and specify my own provider and providerFactory,
In admin console, when trying to create the federation "custom-ldap", most
of the input fields do not have a label and some buttons like "Test
connection" are missing. The configuration property that I added and
customized has label/default value/tooltip.
Hard to say without looking at the specific code, trying to implement this.
But I would assume, those fields aren't available because the custom
federation
LDAP provider doesn't implement the underlying interface methods, that
are actually responsible for performing the action, when particular button
is clicked?
What happens, if you override the specific methods from the default LDAP
provider, responsible for accessing these fields, and point them back
to the default implementation (e.g. by calling super() with the same args /
params within the overridden interface method)?
If it is not possible to extend the form, is there an easy way how to
inherit the same UI form from the ldap federation page in my extension?
Is the issue, that you can't see the fields, newly introduced by your
custom LDAP
federation provider, or that some fields from the default screen aren't
accessible /
usable upon the implementation of that a provider? Or both?
(Im new to keycloak, and do not have experience with Freemarker).
Thank you so much for your support,
David
Regards, Jan
4:22 a.m.
Goal:
Setup custom federation which extends ldap provider.
Thank you so much for the fast reply!
On the following link there is a module that works as an example of what I
was trying to accomplish and its jar:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1W3vFZu5lPW0x_AXMc5HPYY_Uh7L1ipwV
To make it running, I copied the jar
target/custom-keycloak-federation-4.8.3.Final.jar to
/opt/keycloak/standalone/deployments/.
I also appended to standalone/configuration/standalone.xml:
<spi name="storage">
<provider name="custom-ldap"
enabled="true"/>
</spi>
Then, I restarted keycloak. If one goes to "User Federation" and creates a
custom ldap the following form is displayed (see image1.pgn, see link
above, its on the root folder), where all the labels are missing besides
the one we created (Display Name, on the bottom) and some buttons like
"Test connection" are missing.
Thoughts on the question:
- on the CustomLDAPStorageProviderFactory we can override
getConfigProperties() and add a new property. By calling
label()/defaultValue()/helpText() we can have the input field full
configured. On the other hand, in the parent LDAPStorageProviderFactory,
most of the defined properties do not have label/defaultValue/helpText
specified, and so, most input fields are empty (no label).
To have the input fields fully functional I was thinking two ways:
1) overriding all properties from LDAPStorageProviderFactory, and specify
one by one their content. But the buttons like "Test Connection" would
still be missing.
2) checking how the input form was created for LDAPStorageProviderFactory,
it uses user-storage-ldap.html. Which is being mapped from app.js.
Question: if we would use user-storage-ldap.html, how to map it to our
custom provider without changing the contents of app.js.
Question: how to extend user-storage-ldap.html for that attribute that we
added initially without having to copy the whole user-storage-ldap.html.
(Once again Im new to keycloak, and do not have experience with Freemarker).
Thank you so much for your support,
David
On Fri, Aug 23, 2019 at 12:54 PM Jan Lieskovsky <jlieskov(a)redhat.com> wrote:
Hey David,
On Thu, Aug 22, 2019 at 2:15 PM David VS <david.vsaraiva(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> Goal:
> Setup custom federation which extends ldap provider.
>
> Question: What is the proper way to extend the ldap federation while
> adding
> one more configuration input? (without changing internal keycloak files)
>
> I followed the steps in
>
> https://www.keycloak.org/docs/latest/server_development/index.html#_user-...
> and specify my own provider and providerFactory,
>
> In admin console, when trying to create the federation "custom-ldap", most
> of the input fields do not have a label and some buttons like "Test
> connection" are missing. The configuration property that I added and
> customized has label/default value/tooltip.
>
Hard to say without looking at the specific code, trying to implement this.
But I would assume, those fields aren't available because the custom
federation
LDAP provider doesn't implement the underlying interface methods, that
are actually responsible for performing the action, when particular button
is clicked?
What happens, if you override the specific methods from the default LDAP
provider, responsible for accessing these fields, and point them back
to the default implementation (e.g. by calling super() with the same args /
params within the overridden interface method)?
>
> If it is not possible to extend the form, is there an easy way how to
> inherit the same UI form from the ldap federation page in my extension?
>
Is the issue, that you can't see the fields, newly introduced by your
custom LDAP
federation provider, or that some fields from the default screen aren't
accessible /
usable upon the implementation of that a provider? Or both?
>
> (Im new to keycloak, and do not have experience with Freemarker).
>
> Thank you so much for your support,
>
> David
>
>
Regards, Jan
4:23 a.m.
Hi,
if you implement the custom userStorage provider, the Keycloak will use
some "generic" page for the admin console and add the configuration
options automatically to the page. This generic approach has some limits
and doesn't allow to have advanced things, like the button for "Test
Connection" as you pointed and the tab for "Mappers" etc.
Specifically for LDAP provider, we have overriden the angular template,
so AFAIR LDAP is the only provider, which doesn't use the generic
template, but has it's own template and it's own angular controller. If
you have the custom provider, which is subclass of LDAP provider, it
will still use generic template and hence button like "Test Connection"
won't be available (+ some other things won't be available). So if you
want to have nicer UI for your provider, you may also need to add some
UI files and change few things in the app.js file etc. You will probably
need to use your own theme for it. This may be quite complicated and
there is some risk of having outdated UI when you migrate to next
version (EG. if you override the app.js file in your theme), so I
personally rather wouldn't go that way.
If possible, I would either try to create LDAP mapper rather than
overriding the whole LDAP provider. Or alternatively, I would live with
the generic UI.
Marek
On 22. 08. 19 14:01, David VS wrote:
Goal:
Setup custom federation which extends ldap provider.
Question: What is the proper way to extend the ldap federation while adding
one more configuration input? (without changing internal keycloak files)
I followed the steps in
https://www.keycloak.org/docs/latest/server_development/index.html#_user-...
and specify my own provider and providerFactory,
In admin console, when trying to create the federation "custom-ldap", most
of the input fields do not have a label and some buttons like "Test
connection" are missing. The configuration property that I added and
customized has label/default value/tooltip.
If it is not possible to extend the form, is there an easy way how to
inherit the same UI form from the ldap federation page in my extension?
(Im new to keycloak, and do not have experience with Freemarker).
Thank you so much for your support,
David
_______________________________________________
keycloak-user mailing list
keycloak-user(a)lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/keycloak-user
1939
days inactive
1953
days old
3 comments
3 participants
participants (3)
-
David VS -
Jan Lieskovsky -
Marek Posolda