[hibernate-issues] [Hibernate-JIRA] Commented: (HSEARCH-776) maxFacetCount returns incorrect results when ordering a faceted query

maxFacetCount returns incorrect results when ordering a faceted query --------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: HSEARCH-776 URL: http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HSEARCH-776 Project: Hibernate Search Issue Type: Bug Components: query Affects Versions: 3.4.0.Final Environment: hibernate 3.6.4, hibernate search 3.4 Reporter: Adrian Meredith Priority: Critical Fix For: 4.0.0.Alpha1 When putting a restriction on facets such as {code} FacetingRequest fr = qb.facet().name("name").onField("someField").discrete().orderedBy(FacetSortOrder.COUNT_DESC).maxFacetCount(10).includeZeroCounts(false).createFacetingRequest(); {code} I would expect the facets with the top 10 results to be returned which appears to be true but it seems some are randomly missing (like the 10 are somehow spread across all results as opposed to the top ten). Removing the max restriction and only returning the first ten entries shows the correct results. for example {code} QueryBuilder qb = ftEm.getSearchFactory().buildQueryBuilder().forEntity(WebResult.class).get(); FacetManager fm = query.getFacetManager() FacetingRequest fr = qb.facet().name("name").onField("someField.id").discrete().orderedBy(FacetSortOrder.COUNT_DESC).includeZeroCounts(false).createFacetingRequest(); fm.enableFaceting(fr); fm.getFacets("name").subList(0, endIndex); {code} The two code examples should return the exact same thing but the don't. The below code is my workaround but as you can imaging this could potentially take a dangerous amount of memory due to it effectively loading the entire index. My WebResult class has OneToOne relations to various other objects (e.g. country)