[hibernate-issues] [Hibernate-JIRA] Closed: (HHH-4288) Filters on collections are ignored

Filters on collections are ignored ---------------------------------- Key: HHH-4288 URL: http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HHH-4288 Project: Hibernate Core Issue Type: Bug Components: annotations Environment: Hibernate 3.2; MySql 5.0.51a; Java 1.6 Stand-alone app - no server Reporter: Eric Ford I have two classes: Topic and Narrative. A topic has one-to-many narratives. I want to impose a filter such that only narratives with a particular state value are returned when I look up a topic. @Entity public class Topic { //unrelated attributes not shown private Set<Narrative> narratives = new HashSet<Narrative>(); @OneToMany(mappedBy="topic") @Filter(name="byState", condition=":state = state") public Set<Narrative> getNarratives() { return narratives; } public void setNarratives(Set<Narrative> narratives) { this.narratives = narratives; } } @Entity @FilterDef(name="byState", defaultCondition=":state = state", parameters=@ParamDef(name="state",type="string")) @Filter(name="byState", condition=":state = state") public class Narrative { private String content = ""; private String state = ""; private Topic topic = null; //getters and setters not shown } @Test public void FindSystemById(){ //for this test, the indicated topic has two narratives, //one is "published" and the other is "draft" session.enableFilter("byState").setParameter("state", "published"); Topic result = null; result = TopicDao.findById(new Long(1), noLock); // assertNotNull(result); //this always passes, as expected System.out.println(result.getNarratives().size(); //this always returns 2 assertTrue(result.getNarratives().size() == 1); //this always fails, obviously } The sql code does not show the filter being applied when fetching the collection. I've tried variations including adding the @Filter annotation to the getNarratives() method only and adding the @Filter annotation to the Narrative class only. I've also tried putting the @FilterDef annotation on the Topic class instead of the Narrative class. None of these variations has given the desired result of only one narrative returned from the getNarratives() method. I am coding with Java 1.6, Hibernate 3.2, and MySql 5.0.51a using Eclipse 3.4 and testing with JUnit 4.