[hibernate-issues] [Hibernate-JIRA] Commented: (HHH-1928) order-by mapping for collections overrides order by in Criteria

order-by mapping for collections overrides order by in Criteria --------------------------------------------------------------- Key: HHH-1928 URL: http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HHH-1928 Project: Hibernate Core Issue Type: Bug Components: query-criteria Affects Versions: 3.2.0.cr3 Reporter: Nguyen Hau Giang Attachments: testcase.zip relating to: HHH-594(order-by mapping for collections overrides order by in HQL) HHH-484(order-by not applied to collections fetched by OuterJoinLoader) Mapping(pseudo code): <class name="Master"> <id name="id" /> <set name="details" order-by="DISP_NO"> <one-to-many class="Detail" /> </set> </class> <class name="Detail"> <id name="id" /> <property name="dispNo" /> <many-to-one name="master" class="Master" /> </class> Same problem as in HHH-594, but instead of querying by HQL, when query by Criteria using join-fetch: session.createCriteria(Master.class)// .setFetchMode("details", FetchMode.JOIN)// .addOrder(Order.asc("id"))// .list(); order-by mapping for collection overrides order by in Criteria: from Master this_ left outer join Detail details2_ on this_.id=details2_.ID order by details2_.DISP_NO, this_.id asc or when creating left-join alias: session.createCriteria(Master.class)// .createAlias("details", "D", Criteria.LEFT_JOIN)// .addOrder(Order.asc("id"))// .list(); generated SQL: from Master this_ left outer join Detail d1_ on this_.id=d1_.ID order by d1_.DISP_NO, this_.id asc The order property specified in Criteria should be prior to order of collection mapping. I think this problem should be fixed as with HQL in HHH-594. For details, please see attached test case.