Hi, I wrote an XML rule with an action specified in "otherwise" part, but the action is not launched when the condition is false :-( Here is my rule : <rule id="TagLib release"> <when> <filecontent pattern="release" filename="{*}Tag.java" /> </when> <otherwise> <hint message="C7.1 : No release in Tag" effort="4" /> </otherwise> </rule> In overview panel, this xml rule is converted in addRule() .when(And.all(FileContent.matches(release).inFilesNamed({*}Tag.java).as(default)) ) .perform(new NoOp() ) withId("TagLib release") It seems that "otherwise" action disappeared ! Any tip ? Gilles. _______________________________________________ Windup-users mailing list Windup-users(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/windup-users

The rule should be formatted as he originally posted: <rule id="TagLib release"> <when> <filecontent matches="{*}" filename="{*}Tag.java"/> </when> <otherwise> <hint message="C7.1 : No release in Tag" effort="4" /> </otherwise> </rule> It sounds like there might be a bug here if the "otherwise" clause is not being picked up. We'll have to look into this! I created an issue for it: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/WINDUP-613 Thanks, Lincoln On Wed, May 27, 2015 at 7:07 AM, Ondrej Zizka <ozizka(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: > I am no expert on <otherwise>, but I think that it has no context of > what was found. > In other words, you are trying to apply <hint>, but Windup doesn't know > what to apply it to. The file is only "known" in the scope of nested > <when> and in <perform> . > Again, that's my guess, someone more knowledgable may confirm or not. > > If I am right, then you could either do a nested <perform><iteration>: > The first would find {*}Tag.java, the nested <when> would find the > pattern, or not: > > <rule id="TagLib release"> > <when> > <filename pathPattern="{*}Tag.java" as="file"/> > </when> > <perform><iteration> > <when> > <filecontent pattern="release" fileref="file" /> > </when> > <otherwise> > <hint message="C7.1 : No release in Tag" effort="4" > /> > </otherwise> > </iteration></perform> > </rule> > > This won't work, we don't have <filename> and <filecontent> doesn't have > fileref. > A chance for you to submit a Jira :) > > HTH, > > Ondra > > > On 22.5.2015 12:14, Gilles Bardouillet wrote: > > > > Hi, > > > > I wrote an XML rule with an action specified in "otherwise" part, but > > the action is not launched when the condition is false :-( > > > > Here is my rule : > > <rule id="TagLib release"> > > <when> > > <filecontent pattern="release" filename="{*}Tag.java" > /> > > </when> > > <otherwise> > > <hint message="C7.1 : No release in Tag" > effort="4" /> > > </otherwise> > > </rule> > > > > In overview panel, this xml rule is converted in > > addRule() > > > .when(And.all(FileContent.matches(release).inFilesNamed({*}Tag.java).as(default)) > > ) > > .perform(new NoOp() > > ) > > withId("TagLib release") > > > > It seems that "otherwise" action disappeared ! > > > > Any tip ? > > > > > > Gilles. > > > > _______________________________________________ > > Windup-users mailing list > > Windup-users(a)lists.jboss.org > > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/windup-users > > _______________________________________________ > Windup-users mailing list > Windup-users(a)lists.jboss.org > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/windup-users > -- Lincoln Baxter, III http://ocpsoft.org "Simpler is better."