[arquillian-issues] [JBoss JIRA] (ARQ-2189) Injection into JUnit rule does not work properly

[ https://issues.jboss.org/browse/ARQ-2189?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.s... ] Björn Kautler updated ARQ-2189: ------------------------------- Description: We just upgraded our Arquillian version to 1.4.0.Final and now the JUnit rules do not work properly. We have a {{LoginRule}} like {code} public class LoginRule implements TestRule { @EJB private SecurityManagement securityManagement; private String username; private String password; public LoginRule(String username, String password) { this.username = username; this.password = password; } @Override public Statement apply(Statement base, Description description) { return new Statement() { public void evaluate() throws Throwable { login(); base.evaluate(); } }; } ... } {code} If we use it in a test like {code} @Rule public LoginRule login = new LoginRule("user", "pass"); @Test public void test() { // do something with login } {code} Unfortunately this does not work anymore, as {{securityManagement}} was not injected and so the {{login}} method in the rule fails which would have used it. With a subclass with default parameter like {code} public class CertainLoginRule extends LoginRule { public CertainLoginRule() { super("user", "pass"); } } {code} and the usage {code} @Rule public CertainLoginRule login = new CertainLoginRule(); @Test public void test() { // do something with login } {code} it works properly. We tested different variations with subclass, without, constructors with parameters, without and so on. The significant part seems to be the parameters to the constructor. If there are none injection works as expected, if there some, injection is not done. :-( was: We just upgraded our Arquillian version to 1.4.0.Final and now the JUnit rules do not work properly. We have a {{LoginRule}} like {code} public class LoginRule implements TestRule { @EJB private SecurityManagement securityManagement; private String username; private String password; public LoginRule(String username, String password) { this.username = username; this.password = password; } @Override public Statement apply(Statement base, Description description) { return new Statement() { public void evaluate() throws Throwable { login(); base.evaluate(); } }; } ... } If we use it in a test like {code} @Rule public LoginRule login = new LoginRule("user", "pass"); @Test public void test() { // do something with login } {code} Unfortunately this does not work anymore, as {{securityManagement}} was not injected and so the {{login}} method in the rule fails which would have used it. With a subclass with default parameter like {code} public class CertainLoginRule extends LoginRule { public CertainLoginRule() { super("user", "pass"); } } {code} and the usage {code} @Rule public CertainLoginRule login = new CertainLoginRule(); @Test public void test() { // do something with login } {code} it works properly. We tested different variations with subclass, without, constructors with parameters, without and so on. The significant part seems to be the parameters to the constructor. If there are none injection works as expected, if there some, injection is not done. :-( -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.5.0#75005)