[hibernate-issues] [Hibernate-JIRA] Closed: (HHH-1635) optimistic locking doesn't work if you change version manually in hibernate object

optimistic locking doesn't work if you change version manually in hibernate object ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: HHH-1635 URL: http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HHH-1635 Project: Hibernate Core Issue Type: Bug Affects Versions: 3.0.5 Environment: Running on debian sarge (stable) linux with spring framework 1.2.7. Reporter: Ryan Essentially i am changing the version value in hibernate manually to an old version in the process of copying modified values from a DTO/View object. I use the version value from when I originally requested the view dto data. From my point of view, I would expect that this would cause Optimistic locking exceptions when the data/version was already changed by another client update. This seems like a common pattern. It does not work in this manner, it seems to always use the version in cache from the load and only consider the version change i make as an updage value rather then an actual change to the version. It seems to me if hibernate intends to just ignore my version changes completely then what is the point of us even having a version property in our beans, why doesn't hibernate just use like a proxy and completely automate versioning, it is like it is teasing us with a property that is there but we can't use? I have asked this problem in the forum and I have seen it asked before in both the forum and the bug tracker. I have spent some time searching for a detailed explination of why this doesn't work how I would expect it to and can't. The topic in the forum I have opened. http://forums.hibernate.org/viewtopic.php?t=957539&highlight=&sid... PLEASE before you reject this i would appreciate and explination i really searched the forums heavily but couldn't find anything explaining this. Clearly I must not understand transaction management and optimistic locking as well as I should, and I just don't understand why this doesn't work like I am intending it to.