[infinispan-issues] [JBoss JIRA] (ISPN-2703) The "machine" attribute of server hinting does not work

[ https://issues.jboss.org/browse/ISPN-2703?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.... ] Martin Gencur edited comment on ISPN-2703 at 1/15/13 9:17 AM: -------------------------------------------------------------- Dan, let me describe the problem more thoroughly. We are starting 3 servers but numOwners is still only 2. We expect that whenever we put certain key/value pair in the cache to node0 or node1, it will be replicated to node2 because it has different "machine" attribute (rack and site are the same for all 3 nodes). The site/rack/machine attributes are configured in the following way: node0: site=primary rack=primary machine=primary node1: site=primary rack=primary machine=primary node2: site=primary rack=primary machine=secondary The test we are running is located at https://svn.devel.redhat.com/repos/jboss-qa/jdg/jdg-functional-tests/trun... After I added a little more logging to the test, I got the following: Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 0, node2: 1 Entry count - node0: 2 ,node1: 0, node2: 2 Entry count - node0: 3 ,node1: 0, node2: 3 Entry count - node0: 4 ,node1: 0, node2: 4 Entry count - node0: 5 ,node1: 0, node2: 5 Entry count - node0: 6 ,node1: 0, node2: 6 Entry count - node0: 7 ,node1: 0, node2: 7 Entry count - node0: 8 ,node1: 0, node2: 8 Entry count - node0: 9 ,node1: 0, node2: 9 ...still the same even with more iterations. The same test already works correctly for both rack and site attributes (I mean replicating to a different site/rack) and the output then looks like this: Entry count - node0: 0 ,node1: 1, node2: 1 Entry count - node0: 0 ,node1: 2, node2: 2 Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 2, node2: 3 Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 3, node2: 4 Entry count - node0: 2 ,node1: 3, node2: 5 was (Author: mgencur): Dan, let me describe the problem more thoroughly. We are starting 3 servers but numOwners is still only 2. We expect that whenever we put certain key/value pair in the cache to node0 or node1, it will be replicated to node2 because it has different "machine" attribute (rack and site are the same for all 3 nodes). The site/rack/machine attributes are configured in the following way: node0: site=primary rack=primary machine=primary node1: site=primary rack=primary machine=primary node2: site=primary rack=primary machine=secondary The test we are running is located at https://svn.devel.redhat.com/repos/jboss-qa/jdg/jdg-functional-tests/trun... After I added a little more logging to the test, I got the following: Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 0, node2: 1 Entry count - node0: 2 ,node1: 0, node2: 2 Entry count - node0: 3 ,node1: 0, node2: 3 Entry count - node0: 4 ,node1: 0, node2: 4 Entry count - node0: 5 ,node1: 0, node2: 5 Entry count - node0: 6 ,node1: 0, node2: 6 Entry count - node0: 7 ,node1: 0, node2: 7 Entry count - node0: 8 ,node1: 0, node2: 8 Entry count - node0: 9 ,node1: 0, node2: 9 ...still the same even with more iterations. The same test already works correctly for both rack and machine attributes (I mean replicating to a different site/rack) and the output then looks like this: Entry count - node0: 0 ,node1: 1, node2: 1 Entry count - node0: 0 ,node1: 2, node2: 2 Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 2, node2: 3 Entry count - node0: 1 ,node1: 3, node2: 4 Entry count - node0: 2 ,node1: 3, node2: 5 -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira