[wildfly-dev] Re: WildFly Cloud Tests

Hi, These tests need some modernisation, and there are two things in my opinion that need addressing. *1 Space issues* Recently we were running out of space when running these tests. James fixed this by deleting the built WildFly, but when trying to resurrect an old PR I had forgotten all about, we ran out of space again. I believe the issue is that the way the tests work at the moment, which is to: * Start minikube with the registry * Build all the test images * Run all the tests Essentially we end up building all the server images (different layers) before running the tests, which takes space, and then each test installs the image into minikube's registry. Also, some tests also install other images (e.g postgres, strimzi) into the minikube instance. My initial thought was that it would be good to build the server images more on demand, rather than before the tests, and to be able to call 'docker system prune' now and again. However, this does not take into account the minikube registry, which will also accumulate a lot of images. It will at least become populated with the test images, I am unsure if it also becomes populated with the images pulled from elsewhere (i.e. postgres, strimzi etc)? If `minikube addons disable registry` followed by a 'minikube addons enable registry' deletes the registry contents from the disk, having a hook to do that between each test could be something easy to look into. Does anyone know if this is the case? An alternative could be to have one job building wildfly, and uploading the maven repository as an artifact, and then have separate jobs to run each test (or perhaps set of tests requiring the same WildFly server image). However, as this test is quite fiddly since it runs remotely, I'm not sure how the reporting would look. *2 Pull request trigger* PRs in wildfly/wildfly execute a remote dispatch which results in the job getting run in the wildfly-extras/wildfly-cloud-tests repository. There is no reporting back from the wildfly-extras/wildfly-cloud-tests repository about the run id of the resulting run. What I did when I implemented this was to have the calling wildfly/wildfly job wait and poll a branch in wildfly-extras/wildfly-cloud-tests for the results of the job (IIRC I have a file with the triggering PR number). The job on the other side would then write to this branch once the job is done. Which is all quite ugly! However, playing in other repositories, I found https://www.kenmuse.com/blog/creating-github-checks/. Basically this would result in * the WIldFly pull request trigger completing immediately once it has done the remote dispatch * When the wildfly-cloud-tests job starts it will do a remote dispatch to wildfly, which will get picked up by a workflow which can add a status check on the PR conversation page saying remote testing in wildfly-cloud-tests is in progres * Once the wildfly-cloud-tests job is done, it will do another remote dispatch to wildfly, which will update the status check with success/failure So we'd have two checks in the section rather than the current one. *Other ideas* While writing the above, the following occurred to me. The reason for the split is that the cloud test framework is quite involved, and IMO does not belong in WildFly. So the remote dispatch approach was used. However, I wonder now if a saner approach would be to update the wildfly-cloud-tests workflow to be reusable so they can be used from WildFly? That would allow the tests, test framework etc., and the workflow to continue to live in wildfly-cloud-tests, while running in wildfly itself. That should get rid of the remote dispatch issues, and make that side of things simpler. It does not address the space issue, but I think if this approach works, it will be easier to deal with the space issue.

Any thoughts/insights are welcome. Thanks, Kabir _______________________________________________ wildfly-dev mailing list -- wildfly-dev(a)lists.jboss.org To unsubscribe send an email to wildfly-dev-leave(a)lists.jboss.org Privacy Statement: https://www.redhat.com/en/about/privacy-policy List Archives: https://lists.jboss.org/archives/list/wildfly-dev@lists.jboss.org/message...