Incorectly bound parameters in HQL ---------------------------------- Key: HHH-960 URL: http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HHH-960 Project: Hibernate3 Type: Bug

Components: core Versions: 3.1 beta 2 Environment: hibernate 3.1 beta 2 and beta3 (presumable other as well) Reporter: Misko Hevery Attachments: Component.hbm.xml, ComponentProperty.hbm.xml, ComponentValue.hbm.xml, HibernateBug960.zip, junit_testcase_HHH960.patch I have a HQL: ========== select stack.serialNo as stackSN, v_p_stack_seal_strips.text as stack_Seal_Strip, v_p_size.number as size from com.sigmaquest.gen.model.Component as stack left join stack.containedComponents as cell with cell.componentKind=:kind_cell left join stack.values as v_p_stack_seal_strips with v_p_stack_seal_strips.componentProperty=:p_stack_seal_strips left join cell.values as v_p_size with v_p_size.componentProperty=:p_size where stack = :stack ========== This gets translated to SQL (on oracle) ========== select component0_.serialNo as col_0_0_, values2_.val_text as col_1_0_, values3_.val_number as col_2_0_ from GEN_COMPONENT component0_ left outer join GEN_COMPONENT containedc1_ on component0_.ID=containedc1_.containerComponent_id and (containedc1_.componentKind_id=?) left outer join GEN_COMPONENT_VALUE values3_ on containedc1_.ID=values3_.component_id and (values3_.property_id=?) left outer join GEN_COMPONENT_VALUE values2_ on component0_.ID=values2_.component_id and (values2_.property_id=?) where component0_.ID=? ========== The transaltion is correct (with some caviats) named bindigs are: 1 :kind_cell 2 :p_stack_seal_strips 2 :size 4 :stack When these get bound to SQL in the above order the SQL is actualy reversed. SQL binding order! SQL ?1?: containedc1_ is :kind_cell CORRECT SQL ?2?: values3_ is :p_size gets bound to :p_stack_seal_strips WRONG SQL ?3?: values3_ is :p_stack_seal_strips gets bound to :p_size WRONG SQL ?4?: component0_.ID=? is :stack CORRECT Needless to say executing the query produces garabage. As far as I can tell the problem is in the way AST transaltes HQL to SQL. It does not always keep the order of the operands as in the above example. I don't understand hibernate codebase sufficiently enough to point you closer to the problem. This bug is a blocker and I am happy to provided any examples/code necesary to reproduce -- Misko(a)hevery.com