For ejb3 subsystem, 2 attributes (bean-cache and cache-container under passivation-store element) changed their access-type from read-only to read-write. The change occurred in WildFly 16 (Dec 20, 2018 <https://github.com/wildfly/wildfly/commit/f8ceb2daac6ee16b27991a402dcda63...>). I created WFLY-11778 <https://issues.jboss.org/browse/WFLY-11778> (Missing ejb3 transformer tests) to track the ejb3 part of this issue. Since there is no structural changes, and the new one has wider access-type, any operations from old version HC should have no problem. Do we still need transformer tests in this case? Thanks, Cheng On Fri, Feb 8, 2019 at 10:41 AM Brian Stansberry < brian.stansberry(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote:

access-type, any operations from old version HC should have no problem. Do we still need transformer tests in this case? A test would not hurt, just to make sure everything else works. If there are no structural changes beyond access-type test should be also very simple. -- tomaz On Tue, Mar 12, 2019 at 3:19 AM Cheng Fang <cfang(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: > For ejb3 subsystem, 2 attributes (bean-cache and cache-container under > passivation-store element) changed their access-type from read-only to > read-write. The change occurred in WildFly 16 (Dec 20, 2018 > <https://github.com/wildfly/wildfly/commit/f8ceb2daac6ee16b27991a402dcda63...>). > I created WFLY-11778 <https://issues.jboss.org/browse/WFLY-11778> (Missing > ejb3 transformer tests) to track the ejb3 part of this issue. > > access-type, any operations from old version HC should have no problem. Do > we still need transformer tests in this case? > > Thanks, > Cheng > > > > On Fri, Feb 8, 2019 at 10:41 AM Brian Stansberry < > brian.stansberry(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: > >> >> >> On Fri, Feb 8, 2019 at 9:07 AM Kabir Khan <kkhan(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: >> >>> TL;DR: It looks like we may be missing transformer tests in the >>> following subsystems: ejb3, infinispan, jca, logging, undertow. I've not >>> dug in beyond that. >>> >>> Full: >>> We have been using ModelTestControllerVersion.EAP_7_2_0_TEMP (containing >>> WF14) for transformer testing until EAP 7.2.0 was released. [1] renames >>> this to be EAP_7_2_0 and points to EAP 7.2.0. >>> >>> In addition I have some WIP to update the full mixed domain and >>> subsystem tests to do the same. When doing this I noticed that the only >>> subsystem that had transformer tests referencing EAP_7_2_0_TEMP was >>> modcluster. I knew messaging-activemq had some changes, which Emmanuel is >>> looking at. >>> >>> I've run the model comparison tool against master/7.2.0: and see changes >>> which might be significant: >>> >>> ====== Resource root address: ["subsystem" => "ejb3"] - Current version: >>> 0.0.0; legacy version: 5.0.0 ======= >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["passivation-store" => "*"]: >>> Different 'access-type' for attribute 'bean-cache'. Current: >>> "read-write"; legacy: "read-only" >>> Different 'access-type' for attribute 'cache-container'. Current: >>> "read-write"; legacy: "read-only" >>> >>> ====== Resource root address: ["subsystem" => "infinispan"] - Current >>> version: 0.0.0; legacy version: 8.0.0 ======= >>> * --- Problems for relative address to root ["remote-cache-container" => >>> "*"]: >>> Different 'default' for attribute 'protocol-version'. Current: "2.9"; >>> legacy: "2.8" >>> >>> >>> ====== Resource root address: ["subsystem" => "jca"] - Current version: >>> 0.0.0; legacy version: 5.0.0 ======= >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["distributed-workmanager" => >>> "*","long-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["distributed-workmanager" => >>> "*","short-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["workmanager" => >>> "*","long-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["workmanager" => >>> "*","short-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["workmanager" => >>> "default","long-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["workmanager" => >>> "default","short-running-threads" => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: [handoff-executor]; missing in legacy [] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: [handoff-executor]; >>> missing in legacy [] >>> >>> >>> ====== Resource root address: ["subsystem" => "logging"] - Current >>> version: 0.0.0; legacy version: 7.0.0 ======= >>> * --- Problems for relative address to root ["json-formatter" => "*"]: >>> Different 'default' for attribute 'record-delimiter'. Current: " >>> "; legacy: "" >>> * --- Problems for relative address to root ["logging-profile" => >>> "*","json-formatter" => "*"]: >>> Different 'default' for attribute 'record-delimiter'. Current: " >>> "; legacy: "" >>> * --- Problems for relative address to root ["logging-profile" => >>> "*","xml-formatter" => "*"]: >>> Different 'default' for attribute 'record-delimiter'. Current: " >>> "; legacy: "" >>> * --- Problems for relative address to root ["xml-formatter" => "*"]: >>> Different 'default' for attribute 'record-delimiter'. Current: " >>> "; legacy: "" >>> >>> >>> ====== Resource root address: ["subsystem" => "undertow"] - Current >>> version: 0.0.0; legacy version: 7.0.0 ======= >>> --- Problems for relative address to root ["application-security-domain" >>> => "*"]: >>> * Missing attributes in current: []; missing in legacy [enable-jaspi, >>> integrated-jaspi] >>> * Missing parameters for operation 'add' in current: []; missing in >>> legacy [enable-jaspi, integrated-jaspi] >>> >>> Although WF16 doesn't provide any domain mode guarantees for previous >>> releases, this will one day end up as a product release and then it is >>> important that we have these tests in place. It is easier to add them as we >>> go along than to retrofit them when that time comes. >>> >> >> Thanks, Kabir for running the check and for the heads up! >> >> This needs to be correct in WildFly regardless of any EAP requirements. >> I believe the domain mode transformation chain from WF 14 all the way back >> to at least 11 is correct. There is no reason it shouldn't be extended to >> 16. >> >> Even though any fix would only come in 16, the correct way to write the >> transformation for something that changed in 15 is as if it had been done >> in 15. Write the transformation code for 15 -> 14 (constants, method names >> etc) and then if there are further changes for 16 -> 15, do those. Let >> future readers of the code read code that reflects the history of the >> management API. >> >>> >>> Thanks, >>> >>> Kabir >>> >>> >>> >>> [1] https://github.com/wildfly/wildfly-core/pull/3664 >>> _______________________________________________ >>> wildfly-dev mailing list >>> wildfly-dev(a)lists.jboss.org >>> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/wildfly-dev >> >> >> >> -- >> Brian Stansberry >> Manager, Senior Principal Software Engineer >> Red Hat >> _______________________________________________ >> wildfly-dev mailing list >> wildfly-dev(a)lists.jboss.org >> https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/wildfly-dev > > _______________________________________________ > wildfly-dev mailing list > wildfly-dev(a)lists.jboss.org > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/wildfly-dev