Re: [forge-dev] reflection to access classes in project dependencies

My motivation for this email is to satisfy FORGE-773. However, this is also related to FORGE-563 and FORGE-424, and resolution could enable other features. I have written a prototype: 1) an implementation of the forge java api interfaces which delegates to java's reflection, offering a read only perspective of java components. 2) a forge module, currently a facet, to search for a given binary class in the project's dependencies and returns the result wrapped in the above delegate. These are demonstrable in a unit test. My dilemma now is how to integrate these into the forge project. There are a few different areas, but I'll start with this: For some callers, a java class is a java class, whether it originates as source code (from the current forge project) or is a class from the dependency set. For example, scaffolding primarily is a read only operation. In this use case, it would be simpler for these clients to have a single interface to resolve classes because whether a class is source or binary is not relevant to the use case. On the other hand, there is a set of classes in a user's project that are modifiable. In these cases, a java class is not a java class. Forge components might want the distinction somehow. There ought the be some distinction of which class is modifiable and which is not. Naively, I took the first thinking that the existing forge java model would be adequate. To have separate java api for read-only and read-write java model objects seems a fundamental addition to the java model which requires much more effort. In absence of such a model, I though to implement 'no-op' for those code changing methods (e.g., Named.setName() would be inert). I assumed that forge component that change source code would have necessary context to know when it is operating on a source code module, avoiding attempts to modify a binary class. So, I'm looking for discussion and consensus on the above. Any thoughts? Regards, John _______________________________________________ forge-dev mailing list forge-dev(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/forge-dev