[infinispan-issues] [JBoss JIRA] (ISPN-9032) OperationsDuringMergeConflictTest.testPartitionMergePolicy random failures

OperationsDuringMergeConflictTest.testPartitionMergePolicy random failures -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: ISPN-9032 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/ISPN-9032 Project: Infinispan Issue Type: Bug Components: Test Suite - Core Affects Versions: 9.2.1.Final Reporter: Dan Berindei Assignee: Ryan Emerson Labels: testsuite_stability Fix For: 9.3.0.Beta1 The test modifies a key in both partitions and checks that each partition still sees its own value for a while after receiving the [merged cluster view|https://github.com/infinispan/infinispan/blob/ee87349f0b134b53b3090f...]. It installs a {{BlockStateResponseCommandHandler}} to block the conflict resolution responses and to keep the pre-merge values in the non-preferred topology owners. However, it does not block the installation of the {{CONFLICT_RESOLUTION}} cache topology. And during conflict resolution the read CH is the preferred topology's read CH, so non-preferred topology owners will ask the primary owner for the value: {noformat} 17:12:07,088 INFO (testng-Test:[]) [JGroupsTransport] ISPN000093: Received new, MERGED cluster view for channel ISPN: MergeView::[Test-NodeI-48950|10] (4) [Test-NodeI-48950, Test-NodeJ-6577, Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686], 2 subgroups: [Test-NodeI-48950|8] (2) [Test-NodeI-48950, Test-NodeJ-6577], [Test-NodeK-2872|9] (2) [Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686] 17:12:07,134 TRACE (stateTransferExecutor-thread-Test-NodeI-p50536-t2:[Merge-10]) [DefaultConflictManager] Cache ___defaultcache attempting to receive all replicas for segment 0 with topology CacheTopology{id=20, rebalanceId=7, currentCH=DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (2)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134]}, pendingCH=DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (4)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134, Test-NodeI-48950: 0+256, Test-NodeJ-6577: 0+256]}, unionCH=DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (4)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134, Test-NodeI-48950: 0+256, Test-NodeJ-6577: 0+256]}, phase=CONFLICT_RESOLUTION, actualMembers=[Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686, Test-NodeI-48950, Test-NodeJ-6577], persistentUUIDs=[40b58191-37f1-4fa4-8e4b-f1a7c17bfa59, 208d742d-ecc9-4792-9dd5-f74d5666f5a2, d8914096-a5a4-4e1e-95a0-27c50fee9999, 7464e58b-5e23-4c1b-909e-4e53055f12ca]} 17:12:07,212 TRACE (testng-Test:[]) [BaseDistributionInterceptor] Perform remote get for key MagicKey{13A4/DDFB0E77/56@Test-NodeI-48950}. currentTopologyId=20, owners=[Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686] 17:12:07,212 TRACE (testng-Test:[]) [RpcManagerImpl] Test-NodeI-48950 invoking ClusteredGetCommand{key=MagicKey{13A4/DDFB0E77/56@Test-NodeI-48950}, flags=[]} to recipient list [Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686] with options RpcOptions{timeout=15000, unit=MILLISECONDS, deliverOrder=NONE, responseFilter=org.infinispan.interceptors.impl.BaseRpcInterceptor$1@241e783a, responseMode=WAIT_FOR_VALID_RESPONSE} 17:12:07,225 TRACE (jgroups-4,Test-NodeI-48950:[]) [CommandAwareRpcDispatcher] Got acceptable response: Responses{ Test-NodeK-2872: value=SuccessfulResponse{responseValue=ImmortalCacheValue {value=B}} , received=true, suspected=false 17:12:07,226 ERROR (testng-Test:[]) [TestSuiteProgress] Test failed: org.infinispan.conflict.impl.OperationsDuringMergeConflictTest.testPartitionMergePolicy java.lang.AssertionError: Key=MagicKey{13A4/DDFB0E77/56@Test-NodeI-48950}, Value=A, Cache Index=0, Topology=CacheTopology{id=20, rebalanceId=7, currentCH=PartitionerConsistentHash:DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (2)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134]}, pendingCH=PartitionerConsistentHash:DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (4)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134, Test-NodeI-48950: 0+256, Test-NodeJ-6577: 0+256]}, unionCH=PartitionerConsistentHash:DefaultConsistentHash{ns=256, owners = (4)[Test-NodeK-2872: 134+122, Test-NodeL-23686: 122+134, Test-NodeI-48950: 0+256, Test-NodeJ-6577: 0+256]}, phase=CONFLICT_RESOLUTION, actualMembers=[Test-NodeK-2872, Test-NodeL-23686, Test-NodeI-48950, Test-NodeJ-6577], persistentUUIDs=[40b58191-37f1-4fa4-8e4b-f1a7c17bfa59, 208d742d-ecc9-4792-9dd5-f74d5666f5a2, d8914096-a5a4-4e1e-95a0-27c50fee9999, 7464e58b-5e23-4c1b-909e-4e53055f12ca]} expected:<A> but was:<B> at org.testng.AssertJUnit.fail(AssertJUnit.java:59) ~[testng-6.8.8.jar:?] at org.testng.AssertJUnit.failNotEquals(AssertJUnit.java:364) ~[testng-6.8.8.jar:?] at org.testng.AssertJUnit.assertEquals(AssertJUnit.java:80) ~[testng-6.8.8.jar:?] at org.infinispan.conflict.impl.BaseMergePolicyTest.assertCacheGet(BaseMergePolicyTest.java:160) ~[test-classes/:?] at org.infinispan.conflict.impl.OperationsDuringMergeConflictTest.performMerge(OperationsDuringMergeConflictTest.java:121) ~[test-classes/:?] at org.infinispan.conflict.impl.BaseMergePolicyTest.testPartitionMergePolicy(BaseMergePolicyTest.java:116) ~[test-classes/:?] {noformat} https://ci.infinispan.org/job/Infinispan/job/master/543/testReport/org.in... Maybe we should use the union CH for reading during conflict resolution instead? Speaking of which, {{PreferAvailabilityStrategy}} sets the {{unionCH}} field in the conflict resolution {{CacheTopology}}, but it is ignored because {{CacheTopologyControlCommand}} doesn't have a field for it. We should set {{unionCH=null}} in {{PreferAvailabilityStrategy}} to make things clearer. We should also try to reduce the number of times we log the cache topology during conflict resolution (even if it's only at trace level).