[jbosstools-issues] [JBoss JIRA] (JBIDE-23473) Application wizard: weirdness and usability issues when using local template via URL

[ https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBIDE-23473?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugi... ] Andre Dietisheim edited comment on JBIDE-23473 at 11/9/16 8:05 AM: ------------------------------------------------------------------- [~aurelien.pupier] I cannot replicate this. Whether I type or paste, the URL is validated and the decorator disappears for me, once the url is valid. I see usability issues though: * *Typing a url is unusable*: validation occurrs on each keystroke. It disables the whole dialog and displays a progress for ~1 second. Typing becomes: type a key, wait, type another key, wait, etc. You cant type continously. We should correct this via ex. delayed validating: Validating only happens once there are no keystrokes for a few seconds. * *Error-decoration is not displayed for file-urls to point to inexistant files (404)*: Formally invalid urls cause a decorator to appear to the left of the text field. Once the url is formally valid, the error marker on the field disappears (https://raw.githubusercontent.c -> https://raw.githubusercontent.co) even if the url is still not valid ex. because it's 404. I believe that there's a switch in failing validator. The url validator is displaying the decorator while the validator that tries to load the file isnt See here: [^local-template-validation-weirdness.ogv] [~aurelien.pupier] can you point me to what I miss? (see my screencast - local-template-validation-weirdness.ogv) was (Author: adietish): [~aurelien.pupier] I cannot replicate this. Whether I type or paste, the URL is validated and the decorator disappears for me, once the url is valid. I see usability issues though: * Typing a url is unusable: validation occurrs on each keystroke. It disables the whole dialog and displays a progress for ~1 second. Typing becomes: type a key, wait, type another key, wait, etc. You cant type continously. We should correct this via ex. delayed validating: Validating only happens once there are no keystrokes for a few seconds. * Error-decoration is not displayed for file-urls to point to inexistant files (404): Formally invalid urls cause a decorator to appear to the left of the text field. Once the url is formally valid, the error marker on the field disappears (https://raw.githubusercontent.c -> https://raw.githubusercontent.co) even if the url is still not valid ex. because it's 404. I believe that there's a switch in failing validator. The url validator is displaying the decorator while the validator that tries to load the file isnt See here: [^local-template-validation-weirdness.ogv] [~aurelien.pupier] can you point me to what I miss? (see my screencast - local-template-validation-weirdness.ogv) -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.2.3#72005)