[
https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBIDE-17984?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugi...
]
Andre Dietisheim updated JBIDE-17984:
-------------------------------------
Description:
In JBIDE-10541 we added a "Publish Changes" dialog that shows the dirty changes
for the local project, allows users to provide a commit msg and to commit/publish changes
to OpenShift.
This resulted in having a "Publish Changes" dialog popping up after the
OpenShift application was imported (application wizard). UX tests revealed that this
dialog is disturbing to users, it is pretty much unexpected for them. We could solve this
via automatic commit as we did so far but this is very much opaque for the user (discussed
it in length with [~maxandersen]). We therefore decided to fully drop any commit and push
when doing the initial import. We just process our changes and keep the imported project
dirty. The user can then push the changes back to OpenShift via the server adapter.
was:
In JBIDE-10541 we added a "Publish Changes" dialog that shows the dirty changes
for the local project, allows users to provide a commit msg and to commit/publish those.
With this in place the application wizard presents a commit dialog in the end and allows
users to commit the changes that the import caused. UX tests revealed that this dialog is
disturbing to users, it is pretty much unexpected. We also think (discussed it in length
with [~maxandersen]) that an automatic commit is not a good thing, it's too much
opaque. The logical conclusion is therefore that we process the changes but have no commit
nor push back to OpenShift.
Application wizard: dont commit nor push changes back to OpenShift
------------------------------------------------------------------
Key: JBIDE-17984
URL:
https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBIDE-17984
Project: Tools (JBoss Tools)
Issue Type: Enhancement
Components: openshift
Affects Versions: 4.2.0.Beta3
Reporter: Andre Dietisheim
In JBIDE-10541 we added a "Publish Changes" dialog that shows the dirty changes
for the local project, allows users to provide a commit msg and to commit/publish changes
to OpenShift.
This resulted in having a "Publish Changes" dialog popping up after the
OpenShift application was imported (application wizard). UX tests revealed that this
dialog is disturbing to users, it is pretty much unexpected for them. We could solve this
via automatic commit as we did so far but this is very much opaque for the user (discussed
it in length with [~maxandersen]). We therefore decided to fully drop any commit and push
when doing the initial import. We just process our changes and keep the imported project
dirty. The user can then push the changes back to OpenShift via the server adapter.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.2.6#6264)