[ https://issues.jboss.org/browse/TEIID-5372?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin... ] Rafal Korytkowski edited comment on TEIID-5372 at 6/22/18 9:33 AM: ------------------------------------------------------------------- I looked at "thorntail-teiid-examples" and one of them "vdb-datafederation" is actually showcasing OpenShift as one of deployment scenarios. We have a lot of good tutorials, but somehow I do not find them unless you point me to them :) I think what we need is to create a page summarizing possible teiid deployments (or maybe there's one?) including wildfly, wildfly with docker, thorntail and openshift. It should be linked from the teiid/REAMDE.md and be part of Teiid documentation. It doesn't make sense to me to duplicate examples using different deployment scenarios. The least I'd do is to point to a document with other deployment options and, depending on how much work it is, use one deployment option e.g. thorntail across as many examples as possible. When using Thorntail, the Docker image you create is never a base one, rather a targeted one for your specific purpose with selected data source drivers, teiid translators, vdbs. It uses maven as a build tool to produce a customized version of Teiid. It's definitely the way forward for microservices. I still think there's a value of supporting a standalone Teiid on Wildfly as a base image. It's an interesting option for building a Teiid instance purely with Docker as a build tool. It also allows to quickly evaluate Teiid giving an ability to start it with just one docker command. No Java tooling and experience needed. Similarly it can be handy for development purposes when working on Teiid core. However, we would need a proper HOWTO. I found https://developer.jboss.org/wiki/QuickstartExampleWithDockerizedTeiid, but I don't think it does things in the easiest way (it's 3 years old now and things got improved). JBoss images I checked are all based on jboss/base (CentOS), which seems to be preferred so I'd stick to that and would not introduce Alpine at this point. was (Author: rkorytkowski): I looked at "thorntail-teiid-examples" and one of them "vdb-datafederation" is actually showcasing OpenShift as one of deployment scenarios. We have a lot of good tutorials, but somehow I do not find them unless you point me to them :) I think what we need is to create a page summarizing possible teiid deployments (or maybe there's one?) including wildfly, wildfly with docker, thorntail and openshift. It should be linked from the teiid/REAMDE.md and be part of Teiid documentation. It doesn't make sense to me to duplicate examples using different deployment scenarios. The least I'd do is to point to a document with other deployment options and depending on how much work it is use one deployment option e.g. thorntail across as many examples as possible. When using Thorntail, the Docker image you create is never a base one, rather a targeted one for your specific purpose with selected data source drivers, teiid translators, vdbs. It uses maven as a build tool to produce a customized version of Teiid. It's definitely the way forward for microservices. I still think there's a value of supporting a standalone Teiid on Wildfly as a base image. It's an interesting option for building a Teiid instance purely with Docker as a build tool. It also allows to quickly evaluate Teiid giving an ability to start it with just one docker command. No Java tooling and experience needed. Similarly it can be handy for development purposes when working on Teiid core. However, we would need a proper HOWTO. I found https://developer.jboss.org/wiki/QuickstartExampleWithDockerizedTeiid, but I don't think it does things in the easiest way (it's 3 years old now and things got improved). JBoss images I checked are all based on jboss/base (CentOS), which seems to be preferred so I'd stick to that and would not introduce Alpine at this point. -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.5.0#75005)