[jsr-314-open] Nested composite component facet insertion/rendering issue

Gang - While looking at #{cc} expression handling, I played around with some simple composite components and noticed the following behavior. If I define a composite component, foo:outer, that accepts a facet: <composite:interface> <composite:facet name="caption"/> </composite:interface> And then use the component, specifying the facet: <foo:outer> <f:facet name="caption"> <h:outputText value="Hello, Facet! (Outer)"/> </f:facet> </foo:outer> I find that things work as expected if I render the facet in the foo:outer implementation: <composite:implementation> <composite:renderFacet name="caption"/> </composite:implementation> And also work just fine if I pass the facet into a Java-based (non-composite) component: <composite:implementation> <h:panelGrid> <composite:insertFacet name="caption"/> </h:panelGrid> </composite:implementation> However, if I define a second component, foo:inner, that exposes the same facet: <composite:interface> <composite:facet name="caption"/> </composite:interface> <composite:implementation> <composite:renderFacet name="caption"/> </composite:implementation> And then attempt to pass the facet into the foo:inner component from the foo:outer implementation: <composite:implementation> <foo:inner> <composite:insertFacet name="caption"/> </foo:inner> </composite:implementation> My expectation is that the facet would be inserted in to the foo:inner composite component (via the <composite:insertFacet name="caption">) and then rendered by the foo:inner implementation (via the <composite:renderFacet name="caption">). However, the facet do contents do not appear in the rendered output. I wasn't sure whether this is a spec issue, implementation or user error, and have not had a chance to debug further. Want to raise this here in case anyone could comment. FWIW, this is running against the Mojarra trunk. I have not tested MyFaces. (I have attached the two composite components.) Andy