Jean ANDRE created RF-12189: ------------------------------- Summary: Risk of duplicate ID on Tab header with facet ? Key: RF-12189 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/RF-12189 Project: RichFaces Issue Type: Bug Security Level: Public (Everyone can see) Affects Versions: 4.2.0.Final Environment: GlasshFish 3.1.2 - JSF Mojorra 2.1.7 - Spring 3.0.6 Final - CDI Annotation- Firefox 10 - Windows 7 (6.1 sp1) Reporter: Jean ANDRE Attachments: Duplicate_ID_html_output.txt Please, evaluate the risk of duplicate ID. We have check the HTML ouptup with w3c validator and we got following error message: Line 81, Column 19: ID "desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-tabTitle" already defined <span id="desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-tabTitle" title="Liste # (2)">Liste Line 79, Column 19: ID "desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-tabTitle" first defined here <span id="desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-tabTitle" title="Liste # (2)">Liste... Line 82, Column 18: ID "desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-closeTabButton" already defined <img id="desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-closeTabButton" src="/NestedWeb/imag... Line 80, Column 18: ID "desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-closeTabButton" first defined here <img id="desktopForm:TAB_ITEM-02-2-closeTabButton" src="/NestedWeb/imag... For the following dynamic tab fragment. {code} <rich:tab id="#{tab.id}" onenter="enterTab('#{tab.id}');" headerClass="tab-header"> <!-- --> <!-- DYNAMIC TABS --> <!-- --> <f:facet name="header"> &#160;<h:outputText id="#{tab.id}-tabTitle" value="#{desktopController.getTabHeader(tab.id)}" title="#{desktopController.getTabHeader(tab.id)}" /> &#160;<h:graphicImage id="#{tab.id}-closeTabButton" value="/images/closeButton.png" styleClass="closeButton" onclick="closeTab('#{tab.id}');stopPropagation(event);" alt="" /> </f:facet> {code} -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators: https://issues.jboss.org/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira