[bv-dev] Bean Validation 2.0 Early Draft: Web Container Clarification Request

Hi All, One area I'd like to see a clarification on in the spec is around the location of the validation.xml in a JavaEE web container environment. The Bean Validation spec indicates the validation.xml is always at META-INF/validation.xml. The JavaEE Platform spec states WEB-INF/validation.xml should be used for web modules. The entire Bean Validation spec has no mention of web modules, and seems to mainly focus on JavaSE. However, it does mention integration points such as CDI and JAX-RS, so I don't think it would be out of line to clarify in the Bean Validation spec for web modules. Otherwise, the JavaEE Platform spec could be changed to no longer state WEB-INF/validation.xml, but previous JavaEE versions already include this, and the TCK uses the WEB-INF/validation.xml location. Therefore, I'd expect a lot of users in the field to be using the WEB-INF location. The Bean Validation spec has the following section (page 206): Unless explicitly ignored by calling Configuration.ignoreXMLConfiguration(), a Configuration takes into account the configuration available in META-INF/validation.xml. This configuration file is optional but can be used by applications to refine some of the Bean Validation behavior. If more than one META- INF/validation.xml file is found in the classpath, a ValidationException is raised. In contrasts the JavaEE Platform spec has (page 127 of JavaEE 7): In order to customize the returned ValidatorFactory, an EJB, web or application client module may specify a Bean Validation XML deployment descriptor. The name of the descriptor is WEB-INF/validation.xml for web modules and META-INF/validation.xml for all other types of modules. --Nathan