Re: [jboss-as7-dev] node0, node1 and port offsets

Hi I've just spent a lot of time tracking down some problems with tests failing with two IPv6 addresses which lead me to some arquillian.xml files, like this: <group qualifier="iiop"> <!-- The server than invokes the exposed EJB's --> <container qualifier="iiop-client" default="true"> <configuration> <property name="jbossHome">${basedir}/target/jbossas-iiop-client</property> <property name="javaVmArguments">${server.jvm.args} -Djboss.inst=${basedir}/target/jbossas-iiop-client</property> <property name="serverConfig">${jboss.server.config.file.name:standalone.xml}</property> <property name="managementAddress">${node0}</property> <property name="managementPort">${as.managementPort:9999}</property> </configuration> </container> <!-- The server that expsoses EJB's via IIOP --> <container qualifier="iiop-server" default="false"> <configuration> <property name="jbossHome">${basedir}/target/jbossas-iiop-server</property> <property name="javaVmArguments">${server.jvm.args}</property> <property name="serverConfig">${jboss.server.config.file.name:standalone.xml}</property> <!-- we use port offsets in the configuration build --> <property name="managementAddress">${node1}</property> <property name="managementPort">10099</property> </configuration> </container> </group> These configurations use both separate node IPs *and* port offsets, and yet the builds for the configurations only use port offsets. This results in Arquillian looking in the wrong place for some servers have actually started. For example, the arquillian.xml configuration above tells arquillian to look for a host running at ${node1}:10099; but the server configuration built by iiop-build.xml uses port offsets, so the second server's managment address is ${node0}:10099. The test fails because Arquillian can never connect to the host ${node1}:10099. We have some tests which use a single node and port offsets, some tests which use distinct nodes and port offsets, and I also expect some tests which use distinct nodes and no offsets. In the past, we have used two approaches to run two servers on a single node: using distinct IP addresses and the same ports or using a single IP address and ports distinguished by port offsets. The first was the standard case; the second was generally used for testing the port offset mechanism, IIRC. We need one or the other but not both. Should we consider returning to that standard in which we use distinct IPs and no offsets for the general case, and only use port offsets when testing the port offset mechanism?. Using two separate interfaces rather than one arguably a more realistic test than one interface with port offsets. Also, having different multi-host configurations for each test makes debugging more of a pain, as it is one less thing you can assume about a test when trying to figure out what is going on. Also, looking at different IPs in two sets of logs is easier and less error prone than calculating offsets in your head in my experience. The problem configurations I saw were in integration/iiop, integration/manual-mode, and integration/multi-node. Richard _______________________________________________ jboss-as7-dev mailing list jboss-as7-dev(a)lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/jboss-as7-dev