[jboss-jira] [JBoss JIRA] Commented: (JBREM-1248) Avoid connecting to a server in catch clause in case of HttpClientInvoker connection failure

Avoid connecting to a server in catch clause in case of HttpClientInvoker connection failure -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Key: JBREM-1248 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JBREM-1248 Project: JBoss Remoting Issue Type: Feature Request Security Level: Public(Everyone can see) Components: transport Affects Versions: 2.2.3.SP2, 2.5.3.SP1 Reporter: Toshiya Kobayashi Assignee: Ron Sigal Fix For: 2.5.3.SP2, 2.2.3.SP4 Due to a change introduced by JBREM-960 , HttpClientInvoker will try to connect to a server again by HttpURLConnection#getResponseMessage() in catch clause. try { ... OutputStream stream = conn.getOutputStream(); ... { catch (Exception e) { String message = "Can not connect http client invoker."; if (e.getMessage() != null) message += " " + e.getMessage() + "."; try { String responseMessage = conn.getResponseMessage(); int code = conn.getResponseCode(); message += " Response: " + responseMessage + "/" + code + "."; } catch (IOException e1) { log.debug("Unable to retrieve response message", e1); } throw new CannotConnectException(message, e); } This second try may succeed depending on server/network condition even if conn.getOutputStream() in try clause fails. From a point of view of users (actually, JBossWS user), - That may consume a connection with an empty body request - On server side, they can't figure out if the empty request comes from this behaviour or just an empty request was wrongly/maliciously sent So the request is going to be - Avoid connecting to a server in catch clause in case of connection failure If that's impossible or too tricky to achieve JBREM-960 at a time, then - Provide a system property switch to skip the conn.getResponseMessage()/conn.getResponseCode() lines