[jboss-jira] [JBoss JIRA] (WFLY-13832) Bug in detecting the org.apache.cxf module

Bug in detecting the org.apache.cxf module ------------------------------------------ Key: WFLY-13832 URL: https://issues.redhat.com/browse/WFLY-13832 Project: WildFly Issue Type: Bug Components: Web Services Affects Versions: 20.0.1.Final Reporter: Tomas Hofman Assignee: Jim Ma Priority: Major When deploying an EAR file which has a sub deployment that uses CXF annotation classes a warning is logged that looks like this: WFLYWS0065: Annotation &#39;(a)org.apache.cxf.interceptor.OutInterceptors&#39; found on class 'de.comdirect.application.mt.wsexample.server.SimpleWsServiceWS'. Perhaps you forgot to add a 'org.apache.cxf' module dependency to your deployment? If you declare a dependency on org.apache.cxf in the sub-deployment, the warning is not logged.  However, if you declare the org.apache.cxf dependency at the EAR level with export=true you still get the message even though the CXF module should be visible. I tracked down the class org.jboss.as.webservices.deployers.WSClassVerificationProcessor located in the org/jboss/as/webservices/main/wildfly-webservices-server-integration-7.3.0.GA-redhat-00004.jar In this class there is a method which logs this message, plus an additional related method: private void verifyApacheCXFModuleDependencyRequirement(DeploymentUnit unit) { if (!hasCxfModuleDependency(unit)) { CompositeIndex index = (CompositeIndex)unit.getAttachment(Attachments.COMPOSITE_ANNOTATION_INDEX); DotName[] dotNames = \{ DotNames.WEB_SERVICE_ANNOTATION, DotNames.WEB_SERVICE_PROVIDER_ANNOTATION }; for (DotName dotName : dotNames) { for (AnnotationInstance ai : index.getAnnotations(dotName)) { AnnotationTarget at = ai.target(); if (at instanceof ClassInfo) { ClassInfo clazz = (ClassInfo)ai.target(); for (DotName dn : clazz.annotations().keySet()) { if (dn.toString().startsWith("org.apache.cxf")) { WSLogger.ROOT_LOGGER.missingModuleDependency(dn.toString(), clazz.name().toString(), "org.apache.cxf"); } } } } } } } private static boolean hasCxfModuleDependency(DeploymentUnit unit) { ModuleSpecification moduleSpec = (ModuleSpecification)unit.getAttachment(Attachments.MODULE_SPECIFICATION); for (ModuleDependency dep : moduleSpec.getUserDependencies()) { String id = dep.getIdentifier().getName(); if (cxfExportingModules.contains(id)) { return true; } } return false; } The hasCxfModuleDependency() method checks a list of dependencies called userDependencies looking to see if there is an "org.apache.cxf" entry in the list. However, there is more than one list of module dependencies which are part of moduleSpec. private final List<ModuleDependency> systemDependencies = new ArrayList(); private final List<ModuleDependency> localDependencies = new ArrayList(); private final List<ModuleDependency> userDependencies = new ArrayList(); I think when you have an exported dependency from the EAR level it may be part of one of the other dependency lists rather than in userDependencies, so what we have is well-meaning code that tries to check and make sure you have the right dependency to support your annotation (because normally missing annotation classes just fail silently so a check is useful to have), but I think it doesn't check everywhere that it should. Since the EAP 7.3.1 patch just came out, I installed that and repeated the test but there was no difference.