missingMessageReceived() never called in NAKACK resulting in memory leak ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Key: JGRP-1618 URL: https://issues.jboss.org/browse/JGRP-1618 Project: JGroups Issue Type: Bug Affects Versions: 2.8.1, 2.12.2 Environment: Java 6 Reporter: Harry Mark Assignee: Bela Ban Fix For: 3.2.9, 3.3 Attachments: 1618-jgrp-patch.jar, NakReceiverWindow.java We are using JGroups 2.8.1 and encountered a memory leak where it eventually ran out of CMS Old Gen memory. The heap dump revealed that the problem was in the xmit_stats ConcurrentHashMap of org.jgroups.protocols.pbcast.NAKACK. After much analysis here's what we found: when the system is under load, messages can start arriving out of order. When the receiver receives a higher sequence number than expected, it requests the sender retransmit the missing messages with the lower sequence numbers. The sender sends the missing message, however the bug in the NakReceiverWindow meant that the missing message was never purged from the Map that tracks missing messages (xmit_stats) because missingMessageReceived() was never invoked. Over time this Map grows and starts using up CMS Old Gen; the only way it would get reduced was when a server left the cluster and the missing messages were purged for that server. In JMX, the MissingMsgsReceived attribute of jgroups:cluster=*,protocol=NAKACK,type=protocol was always zero, confirming that it never purged any received "missing messages". When I looked at the most recent GA version 3.2.8 of NakReceiverWindow.java , it has the corrected logic that ensures that missingMessageReceived() is called. I checked the the most recent 2.x, which is 2.12.2, and found it also has the same bug in the logic as 2.8.1. This bug may apply to other 2.x but I did not check. Attached is the fixed NakReceiverWindow.java for 2.8.1. After applying the patch, the memory leak went away.