[JBoss Messaging Users] - Re: paging problem with orderingGroup enabled
by gaohoward
Re: So I send a message with ordering group G1 to a Queue. This message is bridged to another server where ordering group attributes are set at the connection factory to group GDefault. Then the messages have the group GDefault iso G1.
Bug or a feature :-) ?
>>> would be a bug definitely. The message's group id should not be overwriten.
Re: But if a message is added to the queue (new message comes in) which have the same orderinggroup, this is registered too on the Monitor. But the message itself is added to the DownCache.
This seams to be a bug or?
>>>No it's not a bug, it is so designed. Paged references are loaded from the beginning and added to the end.
RE: If a message is added to a "full" queue which is paged then this should not be registered to the monitor, or?
>>>I need to think about it.
View the original post : http://www.jboss.org/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&p=4252273#4252273
Reply to the post : http://www.jboss.org/index.html?module=bb&op=posting&mode=reply&p=4252273
14 years, 8 months
[JBoss Messaging Users] - Re: paging problem with orderingGroup enabled
by mclu
Hi Howard!
I investigated my problem more deeply.
First I have to say, that the OrderingGroup of bridged messages are overwritten by the setting in the connection factory.
Not that nice I think.
So I send a message with ordering group G1 to a Queue. This message is bridged to another server where ordering group attributes are set at the connection factory to group GDefault. Then the messages have the group GDefault iso G1.
Bug or a feature :-) ?
Second:
I have added some tracing to the OrderingGroupMonitor to see what is registered and what completed.
While my server starts up it loaded the first 20 paged messages and adds them to the OrderingGroupMonitor. Then it starts handling the messages and calls completed on the Monitor, which removed the ref from the group.
After 5 messages are handled the JDBCPersistenceManager loads the next 5 paged messages and adds them.
That behaviour is fine!
But if a message is added to the queue (new message comes in) which have the same orderinggroup, this is registered too on the Monitor. But the message itself is added to the DownCache.
This seams to be a bug or?
If a message is added to a "full" queue which is paged then this should not be registered to the monitor, or?
Maybe this is the reason, why the delivery stops....
The behaviour you can see below:
| 20 times registering:
|
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740253458432' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740257849345' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740259258370' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740260470787' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740261191684' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740262076421' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740262600710' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740263747591' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740264697864' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740265484297' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740267089930' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740268236811' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740269252620' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740270006285' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740270530574' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740272136207' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740273217552' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740274888721' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740275707922' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:28:50,359 TRACE @main [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154740276363283' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
|
| //Bridge starts adding messages from another server (BUG?)
| 11:29:08,828 TRACE @WorkerThread#2[10.4.16.38:1529] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743382081536' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:29:09,031 TRACE @WorkerThread#2[10.4.16.38:1529] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743382966273' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:29:09,109 TRACE @WorkerThread#2[10.4.16.38:1529] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743383293954' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
|
| // first message is send
| 11:29:10,000 TRACE @Thread-27 [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] marked sending MID '41154740253458432' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup'
|
| // other are added meanwhile
| 11:29:10,203 TRACE @WorkerThread#0[10.4.16.38:1523] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743387783179' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:29:10,421 TRACE @WorkerThread#0[10.4.16.38:1523] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743388667916' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
| 11:29:10,718 TRACE @WorkerThread#0[10.4.16.38:1523] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] restistered MID '41154743389880333' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
|
| // first message completed
| 11:29:13,781 TRACE @WorkerThread#0[10.4.16.38:1523] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] completed MID '41154740253458432' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup' and Destination 'incomingSyncRequests'
|
| // second marked sending...
| 11:29:13,781 TRACE @WorkerThread#0[10.4.16.38:1523] [org.jboss.messaging.core.impl.OrderingGroupMonitor] marked sending MID '41154740257849345' for OrdGrp 'IMSDefaultGroup'
| and so on.
|
View the original post : http://www.jboss.org/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&p=4252261#4252261
Reply to the post : http://www.jboss.org/index.html?module=bb&op=posting&mode=reply&p=4252261
14 years, 8 months