Will do, Max. the patch they used is exactly the same as the one I used and I was asked by David Williams if there were any other patches we included. I told him no and those should be ok. I'll try to test it ASAP but I'm diving deep into Marshall's head at the moment. I strongly believe it should be fine. I will test it anyway. Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/releases/2.0.3/ > > Seems like important fixes of ours got in. > > Rob, care to test/verify/comment that this one works as good as the > patch we currently require for JBoss Tools 2.1.x ? > > -max > >

Max, I think to confirm that we have to pass it though QA. That means QA will install JBT 2.1.2 and WTP 2.0.3 and run at least smoke tests and tests related to deployment problems. Denis. Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > Anyone confirmed wether WTP 2.0.3 will work with JBT 2.x ? > > /max > >> Will do, Max. the patch they used is exactly the same as the one I >> used and I was asked by David Williams if there were any other patches >> we included. I told him no and those should be ok. I'll try to test >> it ASAP but I'm diving deep into Marshall's head at the moment. >> >> I strongly believe it should be fine. I will test it anyway. >> >> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>> http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/releases/2.0.3/ >>> >>> Seems like important fixes of ours got in. >>> >>> Rob, care to test/verify/comment that this one works as good as the >>> patch we currently require for JBoss Tools 2.1.x ? >>> >>> -max >>> >>> >> > > >

Such as? Do you mean EAR deployment problems Rob fixed for last release?

Testing only specific low level technical bugs is not enough to confirm JBT 2.x works with WTP 2.0.3., general QA test cases should be also executed before we decide to release something.

Denis. Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > If QA has tests for this very specific low level technical bug then > sure. > > But I do not believe they have. > > -max > >> Max, >> >> I think to confirm that we have to pass it though QA. That means QA >> will install JBT 2.1.2 and WTP 2.0.3 and run at least smoke tests and >> tests related to deployment problems. >> >> Denis. >> >> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>> Anyone confirmed wether WTP 2.0.3 will work with JBT 2.x ? >>> >>> /max >>> >>>> Will do, Max. the patch they used is exactly the same as the one I >>>> used and I was asked by David Williams if there were any other >>>> patches we included. I told him no and those should be ok. I'll try >>>> to test it ASAP but I'm diving deep into Marshall's head at the >>>> moment. >>>> >>>> I strongly believe it should be fine. I will test it anyway. >>>> >>>> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>>>> http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/releases/2.0.3/ >>>>> >>>>> Seems like important fixes of ours got in. >>>>> >>>>> Rob, care to test/verify/comment that this one works as good as the >>>>> patch we currently require for JBoss Tools 2.1.x ? >>>>> >>>>> -max >>>>> >>>>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> > > >

> On Tue, 05 Aug 2008 01:13:59 +0200, Denis Golovin > <dgolovin(a)exadel.com&gt; wrote: > >> Such as? >> Do you mean EAR deployment problems Rob fixed for last release? > > Yes, that is what the fixes in there is for. > >> Testing only specific low level technical bugs is not enough to >> confirm JBT 2.x works with WTP 2.0.3., general QA test cases should >> be also executed before we decide to release something. > > I don't want to release anything - that is the point. > I want to be able to tell/know if users should just use the latest WTP > instead of our patch. > > Very few things changed in WTP 2.0.3. > > -max > >> >> Denis. >> >> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>> If QA has tests for this very specific low level technical bug then >>> sure. >>> >>> But I do not believe they have. >>> >>> -max >>> >>>> Max, >>>> >>>> I think to confirm that we have to pass it though QA. That means QA >>>> will install JBT 2.1.2 and WTP 2.0.3 and run at least smoke tests >>>> and tests related to deployment problems. >>>> >>>> Denis. >>>> >>>> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>>>> Anyone confirmed wether WTP 2.0.3 will work with JBT 2.x ? >>>>> >>>>> /max >>>>> >>>>>> Will do, Max. the patch they used is exactly the same as the one >>>>>> I used and I was asked by David Williams if there were any other >>>>>> patches we included. I told him no and those should be ok. I'll >>>>>> try to test it ASAP but I'm diving deep into Marshall's head at >>>>>> the moment. >>>>>> >>>>>> I strongly believe it should be fine. I will test it anyway. >>>>>> >>>>>> Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: >>>>>>> http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/releases/2.0.3/ >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Seems like important fixes of ours got in. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Rob, care to test/verify/comment that this one works as good as >>>>>>> the patch we currently require for JBoss Tools 2.1.x ? >>>>>>> >>>>>>> -max >>>>>>> >>>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> >> > > >