Eliminate DeploymentUnitElement "allowed" field ----------------------------------------------- Key: JBAS-8495 URL: https://jira.jboss.org/browse/JBAS-8495 Project: JBoss Application Server Issue Type: Task Security Level: Public (Everyone can see) Reporter: Brian Stansberry Assignee: Brian Stansberry Fix For: 7.0.0.M1 [10:19am] bstansberry: right now DeploymentUnitElement has this "allowed" property [10:20am] bstansberry: which if false is supposed to mean that deployment is ineligible to be mapped to a ServerGroup [10:20am] bstansberry: I'm inclined to trash that [10:20am] bstansberry: any opinions? [10:21am] bstansberry: having it means having a separate class ServerGroupDeploymentElement, plus we'd need to have update operations to toggle "allowed" [10:21am] dmlloyd: it's basically a domain-wide disable of the deployment, right? [10:21am] bstansberry: yeah [10:22am] dmlloyd: doesn't ServerGroupDeploymentElement also have an "allowed" field? [10:22am] bstansberry: no, it has "start" [10:22am] bstansberry: which is whether it's actually deployed [10:22am] bstansberry: (could use a rename, but that's another issue) [10:22am] dmlloyd: hmm [10:22am] dmlloyd: well I envision those two as being the same thing [10:23am] dmlloyd: the global "allowed" flag would restrict deployment, not mapping [10:23am] bstansberry: I don't think "allowed" as a kind of shortcut to undeploy things is worth it [10:23am] bstansberry: if users want something undeployed, update the server group [10:24am] dmlloyd: the use case would be, someone discovers a security issue in a deployment which is mapped to 45 server groups [10:24am] bstansberry: create a deployment plan and fix it [10:24am] dmlloyd: I guess they could just remove the deployment globally [10:24am] bstansberry: "allowed" is just a shortcut for a deployment plan [10:24am] bstansberry: with vague semantics unless we write some really nice documentation [10:25am] dmlloyd: I guess I'm willing to trust deployment plans -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. - If you think it was sent incorrectly contact one of the administrators: https://jira.jboss.org/secure/Administrators.jspa - For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira