Hi im using a primary and secondry table. the user wants to write a review which is inserted into the secondry table and he has the option to edid his review. when i use @Out annotation to the secondry table the user cant able to write into the database it giving the error Caused by: javax.ejb.EJBTransactionRolledbackException if i remove the @out annotation write review is working but editing the review is not working In my bean i declared the coding as TblReviews is primary table TblUserReviews is secondry table @RequestParameter | BigDecimal revid; | @In(required=false) | TblReviews tr=new TblReviews(); | @In(required=false) | @Out(required=false) | TblUserReviews tblu; | @Out(required=false) | List<TblUserReviews> editreview; public String register() { | tr.setProductId(pro); | tr.setUserId(identity.getUsername()); | Set<TblUserReviews> tblUserReviewsCollection= new TreeSet<TblUserReviews>(); | tblu.setReviewEntryId(tr); | tblUserReviewsCollection.add(tblu); | tr.setTblUserReviewsCollection(tblUserReviewsCollection); | em.persist(tr); | return "/prodis.xhtml"; | } public String edit() { | em.merge(tblu); | return "/prodis.xhtml"; | } public void editReview(){ | editreview= (List<TblUserReviews>) em.createQuery("select p from TblUserReviews p where userReviewId="+revid+"").getResultList(); | tblu = (TblUserReviews) editreview.get(0); | | } write review page Code: | <h:inputTextarea value="#{tblu.reviewSummary}" style="width : 445px; height : 109px;"/> | <h:commandButton value="Submit Review" action="#{search.register}" type="submit"/> edit review page <h:inputTextarea value="#{tblu.reviewSummary}" style="width : 445px; height : 109px;"/> | <h:commandButton value="Submit Review" action="#{search.edit}" type="submit"/> i need this urgent thanking u regards kaviarasu View the original post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&p=4082480#... Reply to the post : http://www.jboss.com/index.html?module=bb&op=posting&mode=reply&a...